Including the return of three "iron triangle" instructors, the reform of the competition system won favorable comments. However, too many variety shows obscure the collision of thinking, dilute the color of debate and greatly increase the proportion of entertainment. Secondly, the level of the wonderful people has dropped, and the group has been replaced by hand in hand, and the debate has become a tear. The tearing of the contestants caused a heated discussion, which greatly affected the image of the program group.
First, positive changes.
1. Personnel changes: In the fourth quarter, He Jiong was the keynote speaker, Cai Kangyong, Ma Dong, Luo Zhenyu and Zhang Quanling were the mentors, Li Dan and Xue Zhaofeng were added, and Ma Dong, Gao Songxiao and Cai Kangyong were recalled as "Iron Triangle".
Li's birthday warm-up is strong, and he can always take over the stalk, so that the debate will not be too cold and too strong. Economist Xue Zhaofeng also broke the image of "straight man in science and engineering" and made all kinds of serious nonsense, which caused a "contrast".
2. Competition system reform: The reformed competition system, to a certain extent, balances the strength of each team, checks and balances Ma Weiwei and other old wonderful people's robbing people and some qualifying groups.
The four most powerful old wonderful flowers each bring a team, which is also to enable new and old wonderful flowers to compete in the same field, break their positions and limitations, spread the charm of debate, and let the views collide with more sparks of wisdom.
Second, negative changes.
1. Entertainment first, debate is dead: entertainment first, debate is dead. Although extreme, it is undeniable that the increasing variety of Chipper's theory almost overshadows the essence of the debate.
It is not only reflected in the title of the party, but also in the excessive pursuit of victory and defeat by wonderful people, and even develops to "grab people" and "hold a group" to win, which actually violates the original intention of conveying ideas, persuading people to think and making people understand each other in the debate.
In my opinion, Chipa said that the basic point of this program is not the increasingly complex word "wonderful", but the simple word "say". From beginning to end, victory is just addition. What matters in a debate is always the topic and content, not winning or losing. From different standpoints, many debates have nothing to do with right or wrong.
External wonders can't hide the positive energy transmitted by the program itself. The tutor and the contestants laughed and laughed, and took each other seriously on some right and wrong issues. They will guide the audience to think from various angles and quietly promote the improvement of social morality while entertaining.
The debate turned into a tear.
Debate means to explain an argument with arguments, point out the contradiction of the other side, and finally reach an understanding. This is what the saying goes, "Reason doesn't speak loudly". However, some wonderful pestering replaced strict logic, roaring replaced clear organization, and even developed from field to field, causing scandals and discrediting the whole program.
The public tearing of Fu Seoul and Dong Jing on the Internet has caused a heated discussion, and everyone knows it. Various rhythms, venting, reversal and accusation have led to the emergence of a conspiracy theory. The image of the wise man once collapsed, and the great sense of disillusionment convinced the audience of Qi Yuan's slogan: "Tear off the mask of hypocrisy and speak well".
In the end, both of them lost, and both of them withdrew from the competition, which did great harm to the image of the program. ?
On the whole, Chipa said that she was in a painful transition period. After experiencing scandals, reorganization and other changes, the fifth season has already aired eight episodes. Whether Chipa can reverse the trend as she said, and make efforts later, we will wait and see.