It is forbidden to practice driving with private cars. Is there a legal basis?
Let me start with a story I met.
I drove to Lushun on business the other day, and the car in front was driving very slowly. I was going to cross this intersection.
Just then, the traffic police seemed to find the problem, parked in front of me and politely asked for a driver's license. At this time, a middle-aged man in his fifties sitting in the co-pilot quickly said that he didn't have a driver's license, so he drove my car out to practice driving because he was about to take the subject three.
Subsequently, the traffic police criticized the two men, and they also realized their mistakes and said, "It won't happen again."
The traffic police gave them a ticket, a fine of 1000 for learning to drive and a detention of 15 days. The middle-aged man was fined 1000 yuan and his driver's license was revoked because he gave it to someone who didn't have a driver's license. It can be described as a heavy loss.
Judging from the current relevant laws, it is a serious driving without a license behavior to practice driving with private cars. Article 99 of the Road Traffic Safety Law stipulates that anyone who drives a motor vehicle without a motor vehicle driver's license and whose motor vehicle driver's license is revoked or temporarily suspended shall be fined between 200 yuan and 2,000 yuan by the traffic administrative department of the public security organ, and may also be detained for less than 15 days.
Obviously, the punishment for driving without a license is very severe.
However, in real life, some people still practice driving secretly with private cars, which is definitely not allowed. Once an accident happens, you will regret it. If it is found by the traffic police, it will also be severely punished.
Many people think that it doesn't matter if something happens, there is insurance. This idea is really naive. Think about it. Driving without a license is illegal. Will insurance compensate you? In the end, all the losses are paid by individuals.
It is very risky to practice driving with a private car, because there is no second set of brake pedal in the co-driver position. In case the students operate improperly, the master sitting in the co-pilot position can't stop it.
There are two meanings. First, don't use a private car to practice driving on the training section. Second, private cars are not allowed to practice on the road. Ask again? What crafts, technologies and skills are acquired through study and practice? Did you do any exercises after taking the official version?
Regardless of whether there is any legal basis. Law is the bottom line of morality. There are many phenomena in life, which are not strictly prohibited by law, but are not allowed by morality. It seems to me that "it is forbidden to practice driving with private cars" has two meanings.
The first layer means that the driver didn't get a driver's license. In order to increase the chances of passing the exam, he used a private car to practice driving. I don't agree with this situation. You can't drive a motor vehicle without a driver's license, which belongs to driving without a license. This is legally justified. When learning to drive or using a coach's car, the coach can guide the essentials and pay attention to safety. The co-pilot has a brake. When there are signs of insecurity, the coach can step on the brakes and coach. The biggest drawback of practicing with a private car is that in the event of a traffic accident, who will bear the responsibility? I think I pay more attention to this meaning and call for not using private cars to practice driving before obtaining a driver's license.
Secondly, even if you get a driver's license, you need to be familiar with driving skills, and you need to find relevant personnel and vehicles engaged in sparring, pay a certain amount of compensation, and learn to master driving skills.
Finally, some people now teach themselves to get a driver's license, but they also need to ensure the safety of vehicle personnel, driving safety, and a good training ground and environment.
In a word, considering the harm to security and society, such an appeal is right. Even if there is no legal basis in some places, it is well-intentioned from the starting point, and driving is no small matter.
People who don't get a driver's license practice driving in ordinary vehicles on the road. It must be driving without a license. But it is not limited to "private cars", so is the use of buses in driving without a license. Only special driving school vehicles accompanied by coaches are allowed.
To answer this question, we must first clarify three concepts. 1. What is a private car? Whether it is a "private" family car relative to "public" or the difference between "professional use" and "ordinary vehicle". 2. What is the concept of driving practice? Is it practicing driver's license or driving skills are not skilled enough to practice hands? Is this slogan aimed at the police inside the traffic police brigade or at the masses? If it is textual research, you can only practice with a professional car, no matter whether the car is "public" or "private"; If you are a car trainer, you can practice as long as you are allowed to drive and have legal car rights. If it is aimed at internal traffic police, it can only show that the leaders of the traffic police brigade care for internal police officers and avoid personal property losses caused by police training.
This is a serious misunderstanding of the law, and the traffic regulations clearly stipulate that driving without a license is prohibited, or that people without driving qualifications drive vehicles.
It is obvious that it is illegal for private cars to practice driving.
Coach car, the co-pilot has a coach, and the driver can have no driver's license. Accident insurance companies will settle claims according to law. The accident is the responsibility of the coach and the driving school, and the students are not responsible. If you practice driving a private car on the road, it's driving without a license, but you haven't practiced. Even if the co-pilot has a coach, you are fully responsible and the insurance company will not pay for it. Do you think it has a legal basis?
This slogan is legally justified, but grammatical errors are not enough. The law stipulates that people without a driver's license can't drive a motor vehicle. Private cars belong to motor vehicles, so if you want to drive, you must pass the examination and obtain a legal motor vehicle driver's license before you can drive. How to practice before driving test? Under normal circumstances, I will participate in driving school training and train in a special training venue under the leadership of a driving school teacher. After the venue training is qualified, the teacher will lead the implementation of road training, and then pass the venue examination and road examination to obtain the internship driver's license. After practicing for a period of time, you can take the driver's license without blaming yourself for the traffic accident. Laws and regulations do not stipulate that the driver's license test must be studied in a regular driving school before it can be verified. There is no prohibition in law. Can we understand that private cars have become popular now, and if you want to take a driver's license, you can teach yourself and then take it? Self-study, go back to the origin of the problem, and it is forbidden to practice driving with private cars. Then, if you are in a closed place, in your own yard, in your own threshing floor, or even in the driving school training ground after work, why not practice by yourself? Therefore, I comment that this ban by the traffic police brigade is a grammatical mistake, not an unfounded law.