This is described in the original text: Lu Bu said to Liu Bei: "The public is a guest, and the cloth is a prisoner. Why not say a word and forgive each other? " Liu Bei's answer is more direct: "Have you seen Ding Jianyang and Dong Zhuo?" Finally, because of this sentence, Lu Bu completely embarked on a blind alley.
But at this point, combined with the description behind, I can't help but have a few questions:
First, Cao Cao Can accepted to kill his eldest son, Cao Ang, and Dian Wei loved his nephew, Cao Anmin, Zhang Xiu and Jia Xu. Both of them devoted their lives to Cao Cao. Later, Pound also called for the assassination of Cao Cao at first, but in the end, the seventh army was flooded. Faced with Guan Yu's kind words, he would rather die standing. So Cao Cao still has a good way to gather people's hearts. Is Cao Cao so unsure of Lu Bu?
Second, if Cao Cao has made his final plan, why did he ask Liu Bei for advice on Lu Bu? Cao Cao is not a man without a definite view, especially in Guandu World War I, when Cao Cao pushed the people to adopt Guo Jia's advice and confront Yuan Shao head-on, so Cao Cao also brought Cheng Yu, Guo Jia and other counselors with him, but it happened that Liu Bei was asked to bypass his counselors at this time, which was the biggest doubt.
Third, if Liu Bei bears a grudge against Lu Bu for having captured Xuzhou, then he can directly say that he killed Lu Bu. Why did he quit Ding Yuan and Dong Zhuo deliberately escalate the problem of Lu Bu?
I will answer these three questions a little. Let's analyze whether Lu Bu will have to go back to Ding Yuan and Dong Zhuo in the future.
Let's start by saying that Lu Bu killed Ding Yuan. When Dong Zhuo wanted to abolish Xian Di, Ding Yuan was the first to stand out against it. At this time, Lu Bu appeared, which was a great battle, and suppressed all the civil and military officials present. Dong Zhuo was scared to retreat to Sanlizhai before the official start of the war between the two armies. After that, Dong Zhuocai lamented that Lu Bu could not be self-appointed. Then Su Li and Lu Bu turned against each other. The original text says this:
A man came out of the tent and said, "don't worry, master." A fellow countryman with Lu Bu knows that he is brave and foolhardy, and he forgets his righteousness. With a pair of golden words, some people say that Lu Bu surrendered, but what? "
Zhuo is overjoyed, and he is a samurai corps commander.
Zhuo said, "What are you going to say?"
Su Su said, "I heard that your master has a famous horse, nicknamed Red Rabbit, which walks thousands of miles every day. You must get this horse, and then use the golden beads to help you settle down. If a watchman talks, Lu Bu will turn against Ding Yuan and vote for the master. "
Zhuo asked Marotta, "Is it true?"
Confucianism said: "Master wants to break the sky, why not hesitate to take a horse!"
The above is the content of the romance of the Three Kingdoms. Lu Bu was completely written as a villain who was greedy for money and forgot his righteousness. But there are also questions. If Lyu3 bu4 is really like this, why didn't Dong Zhuo think that Lyu3 bu4 would turn against himself in the future? If the powerful Yuan Shao or Liu Biao, a rich place in Jingzhou, took out more gold and silver, would Lu Bu treat himself like Ding Yuan? Moreover, Dong Zhuo is surrounded by Marotta, a counselor, and it is impossible to analyze the stakes.
Look at the records in the official history. At first, Su Li only proposed red hare, and later Dong Zhuo added gold and silver jewelry and jade belt. In the dialogue between Su Li and Lu Bu, Lu Bu's prologue is a set of regrets:
"I'm at Ding Jianyang's place," said Bu in shock. . "I am also very helpless."
Su Su said, "My good brother has the ability to sail. Who doesn't respect him in the four seas? Fame and fortune are like taking things from the bag. How can you say that you are helpless and inferior? "
Step said, "I hate not to meet its main ear."
Xiao Su said, "Good birds choose wood to live in, and good ministers choose the right time to walk. It is not too early to see the opportunity now, but it is too late to regret it. "
In fact, it is inappropriate for Ding Yuan to deal with Lu Bu. Lyu3 bu4 has the courage to make a westward journey, but the official position given to Lyu3 bu4 by Ding Yuan is only the main book. What kind of official position was the "master book" in the Eastern Han Dynasty? In the Eastern Han Dynasty, the master book belonged to the clerical assistant under the Chief Executive. In today's words, it is the office of the leading secretary. There have been new changes since the Sui and Tang Dynasties, and the specific content has nothing to do with this article, so I won't introduce it in detail.
Ding Yuan's official position is secretariat, while the official positions of Zhou Secretariat and Zhou Mu in the Eastern Han Dynasty are equivalent to today's provinces, and Zhou Mu has a corresponding title, while Zhou Mu has no title. In other words, Dingyuan, as the state secretariat, has official positions such as captain, corps commander and yamen banner. The official position of a master book is obviously lost to the talent of Lu Bu. It is not surprising that a person who has been short of talents for a long time, especially a person whose talents have been affirmed, suddenly faces a person who knows his talents and promises to reuse himself, and the desire to change jobs will arise instantly.
Therefore, Ding Jianyang's death did have the reasons of Lu Bu, but his own reasons were equally important. You have a tiger, but you feed it vegetables and fish every day, but you don't give him meat. The ending can be imagined.
Besides, when Lu Bu killed Dong Zhuo, if Dong Zhuo could explain his legitimacy in the DPRK more or less as a prime minister and a surname at the beginning, then when Lu Bu killed him, he had to accept the demise, which means that it was impossible to say from justice or reason at that time. And Lu Bu's killing Dong Zhuo also seemed so obedient.
The Romance of the Three Kingdoms, marked by Wang Situ's ingenious serial sacrifice, successfully led to the opposition between Lu Bu and Dong Zhuo. But in the official history, it is not. In the official history, after Lu Bu killed Ding Yuan, he took over the Bing Army and became the commander-in-chief of the Bing Army. Dong Zhuo's main troops belong to Liangzhou Army, such as Niu Fu, Li Jue, Guo Si, Hua Xiong, Fan Chou and Zhang Ji. Bing army is mainly Lu Bu, Zhang Liao and Yang Feng. Therefore, no matter in terms of strength or combat power, the Bing army represented by Lu Bu was at a disadvantage and was suppressed by Liangzhou Army. Dong Zhuo was originally a Liangzhou army, and naturally he was partial to Liangzhou army. This in itself caused the dissatisfaction of Lu Bu and Zhang Liao. Then there was a dispute between Lu Bu and Dong Zhuo in history. Dong Zhuo, who is in power now, is no longer a lean man with the world in his heart. More and more domineering, he once threw a broken arrow at Lu Bu, which suddenly made Lu Bu's heart even colder. He was always worried that Dong Zhuo would really kill himself one day. In particular, Lu Bu later had an affair with one of Dong Zhuo's concubines, which deepened Lu Bu's inner anxiety. At this time, Stuart Wang Yun took the opportunity to stir up Lu Bu, which intensified the contradiction between Bing Army and Liangzhou Army, and also intensified the contradiction between Lu Bu and Dong Zhuo. Later, in a battle between Dong Zhuo and Yuan Shao, Lu Bu suddenly turned against him and killed Dong Zhuo.
Judging from the fact that Lu Bu killed his master twice, it was his master's actions that made him feel sorry for himself. And if Cao Cao really gave Lu a high position, especially Cao Cao's handling of the relationship between veteran camp and foreign camp would be better than Dong Zhuo's. So will Lyu3 bu4 sail against the current three times? Here, although I can't arbitrarily say that I will rebel, I also think there is still a chance to rebel. Because Lu Bu's bing army was driven out of Chang 'an by Liangzhou soldiers, Lu Bu began to mature, and it was precisely because of this maturity that he had the ambition to conquer the world.
Although Cao Cao would regard him as a guest of honor, not all of them were Cao Cao's aides in the Han Dynasty, and there were many officials in the Han Dynasty. What about Lu Bu in this camp? In particular, celebrities all agree that Lu Bu is a selfish villain, and there are inevitably people in Cao Cao's camp who are dissatisfied with Lu Bu, especially Zhang Liao, Wei Ji, Song Xian, Hou Cheng or Lu Bu. Lu Bu has a huge sphere of influence in Cao Cao's camp, and such Lu Bu is not easily controlled by Cao Cao Can.
Regarding the question that Cao Cao asked Liu Bei in the White Gate Tower, I think it may also be a temptation for Cao Cao to ask Liu Bei. If Cao can't make up his mind, he can ask his advisers around him instead of asking the guests for the final decision. Besides, as I said before, Cao Cao is by no means a scheming master. Therefore, combined with the first point, he should still be more inclined to kill Liu Bei. But Chen Gong, Seibel and Zhang Liao under Lu Bu are all talents that Cao Cao is eager to get. If he kills Lu Bu rashly, these military commanders will definitely hate Cao Cao and will never follow him. At the same time, through dealing with Liu Bei several times, Cao Cao's attitude towards Liu Bei was eager to win over at first, but later he and his advisers found that Liu Bei was not a poor man, especially in the paragraph about the hero cooking wine. Cao Cao bluntly said that the future world disputes must be launched between himself and Liu Bei.
And Liu Bei also saw that Cao Cao was testing his intentions. If Liu Bei says not to kill Lu Bu at this time, then Lu Bu will turn against him in the future, and Cao Cao will have 10,000 reasons to destroy Liu Bei first. When you killed Lu Bu, you showed that you could read Cao Cao's mind. The point is that you are not from Cao Cao, so you will soon fall into a terrible situation. So Liu Bei's answer at this time was quite clever, and he moved Ding Yuan and Dong Zhuo out.
In addition, Cao Cao's temptation has another purpose, that is, to observe Liu Bei's tolerance, because Lu Bu had a holiday with Liu Bei when he took Xuzhou, and then Lu Bu also had a classic move of shooting halberd at Yuanmen, which offended Liu Bei's last lifeline, Yuan Shu. It can be said that Liu Bei's answer at this time is also to decide his own life and death. Once the answer is wrong, he will fall into a fatal disaster. When Lu Bu was pushed down, he didn't hate Cao Cao too much, but cursed Liu Bei. At this time, Liu Bei also breathed a sigh of relief, at least saving Lu Bu's life.
A question about Lu Bu also reflects a high-level game. Cao Cao, who has won the first big winner, has opened the market, and Liu Bei's chance of winning is only half. Lyu3 bu4 is not without the possibility of winning. But just because of one sentence, the direction of this puzzle was nailed, completely changing the future pattern. I have to say that Liu Bei is actually very clever. Cao Cao's opening is only a victory on paper.