Current location - Quotes Website - Excellent quotations - Why can't Guan Yu's death and Zhang Fei's death be compared among the three countries?
Why can't Guan Yu's death and Zhang Fei's death be compared among the three countries?
Sima Qian once said that death is lighter than a feather and heavier than Mount Tai. In fact, it is more appropriate to describe the deaths of Guan Yu and Zhang Fei. Guan Yu's death is heavier than Mount Tai, and Zhang Fei's death is lighter than a feather.

Guan Yu and Zhang Fei are Liu Bei's right-hand men and two thugs that Liu Bei trusts very much. Liu Bei once left Xuzhou for Zhang Fei to guard. At that time Liu Bei only had Xuzhou, but he lost it. It doesn't matter. Land is like clothes, brothers are brothers.

Later, Liu Bei gave Jingzhou to Guan Yu, and Guan Yu lost Jingzhou as a result. Liu Bei couldn't hold back this time. When he wanted to say that famous saying, he couldn't say it.

Because his two good brothers have died one after another. Many experts found that the Three Oaths of Taoyuan were false and there was no historical record, so they were complacent, just like Columbus who discovered the New World. In fact, what they don't know is that Liu is more intimate than his own brother.

0 1 Guan Yu never intended to escape alive after losing Jingzhou.

In fact, for Guan Yu, there is more than one way to live. If he wants to drag out an ignoble existence, he can even surrender to Soochow. There is no problem in how to escape back to surprisingly, as long as he grasps the time.

Then why didn't Guan Yu run away? Because he was sorry for Liu Bei and felt that he had lost Jingzhou. He really felt sorry for Liu Bei. Guan Yu was not killed by Wu Dong, but committed suicide.

At that time, Guan Yu was desperately attacking Fancheng. At this time, Cao Cao has contacted Sun Quan. Cao Cao let Sun Quan sneak attack Jingzhou, and Jingzhou was Sun Quan's from now on.

With this advantage, I know that Sun is clearing Cao Cao's way, and he is going to sneak attack. Guan Yu was in full swing at the front, but suddenly the backyard caught fire.

Lu Meng led his troops into Jingzhou to make enemies with Mi Fang and Fu Shiren. Then Nanjun fell into the hands of Lv Meng. At this time, if the troops led by Guan fled to the west, there would be no way out. After all, there is no sign of defeat, and no one dares to chase this god of war easily.

Plus Mi Fang, the satrap of Nanjun County, is in Jiangling, and the sergeant Ren Tun is in charge of public security, so he always thinks that his feathers are lighter than himself. Feather out of the army, Fang Ren provided military resources, but they didn't know how to save each other. Feather words? Still cure? , Fang, RenXian a full face of fear. Therefore, power yin lures Fang and benevolence, and Fang and benevolence make people welcome power. Tso sent Huang Xu to save Coss, and the troops returned. The power has been taken from Jiangling, the wives of the feather scholars have been captured, and the feather army has dispersed. The right to send the generals to attack the feathers, cut the feathers and level with Linzhou. -History of the Three Kingdoms

However, Guan Yu did not escape, but went directly to Jingzhou with Jingzhou soldiers to rescue him, hoping to recapture his territory from Lv Meng. But at this time, a new problem appeared, and the families of Jingzhou soldiers were controlled by Lv Meng.

Lv Meng was very concerned about the families of Jingzhou soldiers and told Guan Yu's Jingzhou soldiers the news. Just like taking your son out to eat snacks at your son's school when you are away, I call to tell you that I take good care of your son, so you must rest assured.

Can Jingzhou soldiers still fight well? One by one, they were all disappointed. At this time, Guan Yu didn't have to fight at all, so he was naturally defeated. In this way, Guan Yu will never have a chance to recapture Jingzhou.

If he can realize this at the first time, he may not be killed, but at least he can escape to Liu Feng in Shangsan County. It's a pity that he thought he could pull back a game, and ended up in a sad end.

Zhang Fei's death was purely of his own making.

Zhang Fei once sold his Zhuangzi to invest in Liu Bei's great career. Moreover, Zhang Fei has always followed Liu Bei and never regretted it.

Therefore, after Liu Bei succeeded, he was actually good to Zhang Fei. Zhang Fei's position in the group is second only to Liu Bei and Guan Yu, and it is better than the relationship between Zhuge Liang and Liu Bei.

Such Emperor III has a fatal weakness in character. Guan Yu likes dealing with soldiers and despises those literati. Zhang Fei is completely different. He likes dealing with literati, but disdains those soldiers.

In particular, he likes to drink, and every time he gets drunk, he will hit his men. Tie up your men and whip them. Who can stand it? You are too violent!

At the beginning, Fei was magnificent and powerful, not as good as Guan Yu and Cheng Yu, the adviser of Wei State, who claimed to be the enemy of thousands of people. Feather is good to the pawn, arrogant to the scholar-bureaucrat, flying to love the gentleman, regardless of the villain. Old Master Q often said: The punishment and killing of Qing are all too bad. Every day, athletes are flogged, and the order is around. This is also the way to bring disaster. ? It is not too late to fly. First attack Wu, lead ten thousand soldiers when flying, and go to Jiangzhou from Langzhong. Face to face, Zhang Da and Fan Qiang were killed under his account, and Sun Quan went down the river. -History of the Three Kingdoms

This is sheer nonsense. How can a general who risks his life not be violent? Especially after Guan Yu was killed, Zhang Fei's temper grew bigger every day, and no one could control Zhang Fei.

So Zhang Fei drinks and beats people every day. Who can stand it? So, the beating department made Fan Jiang Zhang Da, and when Zhang Fei was drunk, he cut off Zhang Fei's head and sent it to Soochow.

It is a pity that Zhang Fei, who is known as the enemy of ten thousand people, died so timid. So many famous soldiers, he died not on the battlefield, but in many details.

For example, the invincible Yue Fei was not killed by Jin people, but was framed and killed by one of his own. General Di Qing, for example, was also an ever-victorious god of war, but in the end he was scared to death in public under the suppression of literati.

Zhang Fei's death undoubtedly added another scar to Liu Bei's grief, so Liu Bei was already ready to avenge them, but the strength at that time did not allow it.

Guan Yu and Zhang Fei are the main reasons for Liu Bei's persistence.

It is not easy for us to look at Liu Bei's life. At the age of 28, I met Guan Yu and Zhang Fei, which was the first bucket of gold. But until he was 48 years old, he still accomplished nothing and could only live under Liu Biao's account.

It has been 20 years since Liu Bei went from poverty to poverty. It's a miracle that he can persist. So what forces Liu Bei to move on? The ambition to revive the Han Dynasty is far from enough. In fact, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei gave Liu Bei strength.

Because Guan Yu and Zhang Fei have always supported Liu Bei, Liu Bei can persist for 20 years. After the age of 48, my career had the opportunity to rise rapidly and realized my original ideal.

In the summer and April of the first year of Zhangwu, the world was pardoned and the title was changed. Zhuge Liang is the Prime Minister and Xu Jing is Stuart. Set up 100 officials, set up ancestral halls, and offer sacrifices to the emperors below. In May, Wu Zetian was established, and her son was the Crown Prince. In June, Zi Yong was King Lu and Li was King Liang. Zhang Fei, the riding general, was badly hurt by him. At the beginning of my father's anger, Sun Quan tackled the problem and marched eastward. In autumn and July, he led the army to attack Wu. Sun Quan wrote a letter to ask for peace, and the first master was furious and refused. General Wu, Li Yi, Liu A and others exiled Wu and Zigui. Wu Ban, Feng and other generals, from the beginning of Wu, divided their troops everywhere, and the army returned to Zigui, while the barbarians in Xing Wu sent messengers to ask for soldiers. -History of the Three Kingdoms

Therefore, the success of Liu Bei's entrepreneurship cannot be separated from the help of Guan Yu and Zhang Fei. Many people say that Guan Yu and Zhang Fei hurt Liu Bei, which is incorrect, because Guan Yu and Zhang Fei helped Liu Bei achieve the day of success, which is actually very difficult.

Three people belong to the type of holding a group to keep warm, and the key is that they have survived. Although they encountered various setbacks later, their feelings never changed. Is there anything more profound than this feeling in the world?

Guan Yu's death was tragic. As a vassal, he had the ability of the Northern Expedition, but he misjudged the timing of the Northern Expedition. After Liu Beigang finished the battle of Hanzhong, he could not support Guan Yu at all, and he had to rely on Guan Yu himself.

Is this realistic? Of course, it is unrealistic, because Guan Yu not only has to face a powerful opponent, Cao Cao, but also guard against an insidious opponent, Sun Quan. So Guan Yu's final death was quite tragic, at least he died on the battlefield.

And Zhang Fei was wronged and killed by himself. If you really feel sad, can't you lead troops to fight to the death with Wu Dong? Do you have to be killed by yourself?