Current location - Quotes Website - Excellent quotations - Refutation of thesis: To refute those who are close to red are red, and those who are close to ink are black
Refutation of thesis: To refute those who are close to red are red, and those who are close to ink are black

Writing ideas: First give your own point of view, and then you can demonstrate your point of view by citing celebrity examples. For example, the world-famous litterateur Mr. Lu Xun is a very good example. The lotus grows out of the mud. But not stained, those who are close to ink may not necessarily be black, etc.

Text:

"When you come out of the mud, you will not be stained; when you wash the clear ripples, you will not be evil." "One who is close to vermillion is red, and one who is close to ink is black." This seems to have become a famous saying through the ages. However, if we think carefully, we can easily find that those who are close to black are not necessarily black.

Whether an ink is black or not is a topic that has been discussed by countless people. Most people think it is black, but some people take a different approach and come to the conclusion that it is not necessarily black.

Black and not necessarily black, I think the key lies in the word "near".

What some people call closeness is closeness from beginning to end. Long-term communication and communication will inevitably have the influence of mutual reference and learning. This is almost the instinct of human beings. Of course, there are situations where two people get along with each other and are very different in all aspects, but do not affect each other. Then one of them must be very principled and unwilling to impose his own will on others. This kind of relationship generally does not last too long. Because there is no spiritual communication between individuals, the result is that they eventually part ways. Some people will definitely say that such relationships can also last for a long time, but most of them are caused by material needs. Without communication on the spiritual level, how can we talk about being close?

There is another situation that is ridiculous. In order to prove that those who are close to Mohism are not necessarily evil, someone deliberately comes into contact with another person who is obviously different. After a certain period of time, no one has affected anyone, so someone Shouted, those who are close to ink are not necessarily black. This is like wearing rubber gloves to wash dishes. Of course, your hands will not be hurt, and your hands will not even get wet.

The so-called closeness should mean communication on a spiritual level. Proximity does not refer to physical distance, but to the interweaving of concepts between individuals. There is only a moment of collision of ideas. If the ideas do not agree, they will separate and go their own ways. This is not close. If there is a resonance between the ideas, then the subsequent exchanges will definitely lead to new thinking. This is close. The near will inevitably evolve.

There are also cases where the proximity between individuals only exists at a certain level, and only at this level can ideas be exchanged. In this way, it will be close to vermilion but not red, and close to ink but not black. There are many allusions throughout the ages to prove this. Again, the exchange of ideas will inevitably lead to evolution.

The so-called proximity in those allusions only exists and is one-sided, or both parties use proximity to obtain something for a certain purpose. To give a simple example, some prisoners released from prison have since changed their minds and no longer do evil; some are still stubborn. To put it simply, those who turn back are those who have good intentions, so they can accept those good things and blend them with their own ideas.

As for those who are impenitent, they block all the persuasion from their hearts, and even pretend to accept it, but in the end there is no change in their hearts. Others may have accepted it with an open mind, but in the end committed another mistake due to poor self-control. This is a typical example. Contact with good people, accept the good things and change them. After being released from prison, you will be exposed to bad things and change again.

Jin Dynasty Fu Xuan's "Prince Shaofu's Proverbs": "Therefore, those who are close to vermilion are red, and those who are close to ink are black; if the sound is harmonious, the sound will be clear, and if the shape is straight, the shadow will be straight." The ancients do not deceive me. Those who are close to vermilion are red, those who are close to ink are black." This is the famous saying of the great scholar Confucius, which has been regarded as truth by people for thousands of years. But I don't think so. I think that "one who is close to red is not necessarily red, and one who is close to ink is not necessarily red". black. ”

The world-famous writer Mr. Lu Xun is a very good example. Mr. Lu Xun was born in a feudal landlord family, but he was very sympathetic to the working people when he was a boy, and did not bully like other rich people. People. As an adult, he used his pen instead of his gun to deeply expose the ugly face of feudal society. In fact, there are many people like Mr. Lu Xun in the world. Those who are close to Mo are not necessarily bad! It is difficult to change people. Even if the people around you are all Zhu, but if you don't learn from them, you will become worse as you learn. So what use are Zhu to you? After all this, do you still firmly believe that "when you are close to red, you are red, and when you are close to ink, you are black"?