This is the article "8 Questions That Left Jack Ma Speechless" that went viral for a while in WeChat Moments. Personally, I feel that this article is very boring and lacks both marketing knowledge and consumer knowledge. , don’t take it too seriously, the eight proposed contents are:

Question 1. Regarding consumption stimulation: May I ask Jack Ma, how to measure the contribution of e-commerce to social wealth? Is the development of e-commerce and the plight of the traditional retail industry a zero-sum game? When millions of sellers surround you on the throne of wealth and business myth, have you ever thought about this question?

Question 2. Regarding tax contribution: I would like to ask Jack Ma, is the contribution of you and your Alibaba to the national tax revenue a zero-sum game compared to the amount of tax evaded by Taobao sellers? Have you ever calculated the harm that low prices will do to the entire manufacturing industry and the impact on national tax revenue?

Question 3. Regarding social employment: May I ask Jack Ma, when you invite the world’s media to witness your Double Eleven myth, millions of people are working all night and continuously overtime, what do you give What kind of employment ecosystem will e-commerce practitioners bring?

Question 4. Regarding consumer quality: I would like to ask Jack Ma, when you threaten the sellers with the price again and again, have you ever thought about the chain reaction of the manufacturing industry? In order to participate in your Double Eleven, sellers have to lower their purchasing quality standards, and manufacturers have to use cheaper materials to produce cheaper goods. Is this a vicious cycle? Is the damage caused by the price war to China's manufacturing industry destroying China's industrial upgrading efforts over the past decade?

Question 5. Regarding the channel revolution: May I ask Jack Ma, when the e-commerce giants headed by your Taobao and Tmall vividly interpret the principle that channels are king, when the channel revolution you advocate evolves into When you set up a separate mountain and charge fees on the ground, are your good original intentions of channel revolution still there?

Question 6: Regarding industry ecology: May I ask Jack Ma, how can we enable businesses to survive well even if they leave your ecology?

Question 7: Regarding business order: May I ask Jack Ma, in addition to achieving your Alibaba myth, this kind of sports promotion has brought great changes to the supply chain, service chain and consumption growth of the entire society. What are the benefits?

Question 8. Regarding the fight against counterfeiting: I would like to ask Jack Ma, have you really tried your best to fight against counterfeiting?