Current location - Quotes Website - Famous sayings - What are the ten inconsistencies between the Yongzheng Dynasty TV series and history?
What are the ten inconsistencies between the Yongzheng Dynasty TV series and history?

There are ten inconsistencies as follows:

1. The death of Sun Jiagan.

1) TV series: When Yongzheng sent him to the northwest for condolences and assistance, he couldn't stand Nian Gengyao's arrogance, extravagance and waste. He cursed and was killed by Nian Gengyao.

2) Historically: Sun Jiagan (1683-1753) lived until the Qianlong Dynasty.

2. Hongli’s appearance time.

1) TV series: In the forty-sixth year of Kangxi's Mulan hunt, all princes and grandsons over ten years old participated. Kangxi appreciated Hongli and gave him a jade.

2) Historically: Hongli was born in the 50th year of Kangxi. Hongli first met his grandfather in July of the 61st year of Kangxi. Kangxi passed away within a few months.

3. The eighth master Yinhu.

1) TV series: The Eighth Master is a hidden avenger, and in the late period of Yongzheng's reign, he tried to restore the "eight kings' political affairs" in an attempt to force Yongzheng to retreat and help the emperor's third son Hongshi ascend the throne.

2) Historically: As early as the third year of Yongzheng's reign, the eighth and ninth masters had been dismissed from their posts, and the third son of the emperor, Hongshi, was also imprisoned until his death very early.

4. The name of the great eunuch.

1) TV series: Yongzheng’s personal eunuch is named Li Dequan, which is fictionalized by the author.

2) Historically: Yongzheng’s personal eunuch was named Su Peisheng.

5. Ertai.

1) TV series: Ertai does not appear in the whole series.

2) Historically: Ertai (1677-1745) was one of the confidants of Emperor Yongzheng and an important minister of the Yongzheng Dynasty.

6. Wear supplements on official uniforms.

1) TV series: Prince Lian Yunsu and the four banner princes all use Zhenglong on the front, back and shoulders of their official uniforms, but they are not golden dragons like those on the Thirteenth Prince.

2) Historically: According to the regulations of the prince, the dragon should be facing forward and backward, and the dragon should be walking on both shoulders.

7. Eating rules.

1) TV series: In the palace, Li Wei accompanies Emperor Yongzheng for dinner. Li Wei cried, dropped rice from his mouth, and said words of comfort to the emperor.

2) Historically: The rules of the imperial palace were very strict, and ministers would not be allowed to be so rude in front of the emperor.

8. The Dead Eagle Incident.

1) TV series: Kangxi’s birthday, the gift given to Kangxi by the fourteenth prince was tricked into a dead eagle by the eighth prince Yinhu.

2) Historically: Historically, the death eagle incident was caused by the eighth prince not accompanying Kangxi on inspection in order to visit his mother's grave, so he gave two sea greens as an apology. Unexpectedly, it turned into a bird in Kangxi's hands. Dead Eagle.

9. Longkodo.

1) TV series: Longkodo, the nine-door admiral, is Tong Guowei's nephew. He helped Yongzheng seize the throne. Finally, he followed the Eight Lords Party to force the palace, and was later placed under house arrest and died of unknown causes.

2) History: Longkoduo was the son of Tong Guowei. Because Longkoduo was arrogant about taking credit, his subordinates made many mistakes and were implicated in the investigation. Finally, he was imprisoned for life by Yongzheng, and soon died of depression.

10. Wu Sidao.

1) TV series: Wu Sidao can be said to be the biggest contributor to Yongzheng’s victory in winning the title of the nine sons. Every time, he was calm, pointed, and gave accurate fables, helping Yinzhen win over adversities again and again, and finally retired with success.

2) Historically: Wu Sidao was just an aide to Tian Wenjing. The greatest contributors to Yongzheng's ascension to the throne were his thirteenth elder brother Yinxiang, and his right-hand men Longkoduo and Nian Gengyao.

Extended information:

In "Yongzheng Dynasty", Nian Gengyao and Li Wei were both servants of Yongzheng in his dormitory, and they can be regarded as domestic slaves for generations. Later, because he was favored by Yongzheng, he began to flourish. However, the status of Nian Gengyao and Li Wei in real history was much higher than that of the slaves.

Nian Gengyao belonged to the Xianghuang Banner of the Han Army of the Eight Banners. He was a serious Eight Banners man, not a slave. His father became the governor of Huguang and acted as the governor of Huguang when he was a senior official. He was a famous official in the border area.

Nian Gengyao was even better than his father. He passed the Jinshi examination at the age of 21 and was awarded Shujishi (senior preparatory cadre in the Ming and Qing dynasties). In the forty-eighth year of Kangxi (1709), Nian Gengyao was promoted to governor of Sichuan. He was just thirty years old this year. It is worth mentioning that the governor's level is equivalent to today's provincial party secretary.

Although Li Wei's background is not as prominent as Nian Gengyao, it is not ordinary either. He is a child of a large family in Feng County, Jiangsu Province.

When he was 30 years old, his family spent money to give Li Wei a job as a foreign minister.

However, no one expected that Li Wei would actually succeed in this "soy sauce" idle job and achieve outstanding political achievements. As a result, he was highly regarded and successively served as a doctor in the Ministry of Household Affairs, Yunnan Yanyi Road, Chief Envoy, Governor of Zhejiang, Governor of Zhejiang, Minister of the Ministry of War, Acting Minister of the Ministry of Punishment, and Governor of Zhili.

After talking about Nian Gengyao and Li Wei, let’s talk about a very exciting plot in "Yongzheng Dynasty", that is, the "Baye Party" Yunhu, Yunhuang and others joined forces with several The Iron Hat King proposed to restore the "Eight Kings' Discussion of Government" and forced Emperor Yongzheng to enter the palace. Later, the conspiracy of Yunhu and others was foiled, and those who participated in forcing the palace were also liquidated by Yongzheng.

However, in real history, there was no such thing as a joint effort to force a woman to have a baby. In the fourth year of Yongzheng's reign (1726), Emperor Yongzheng found an excuse to deprive Yunsu and Yunsu of their titles and imprisoned them in the clan's mansion. They died suddenly one after another not long after, and the cause of death is unknown.

Another obvious mistake in "Yongzheng Dynasty" is that in the play, Prince Cheng Yunzhi, the third brother of Emperor Yongzheng, always plays a good old man. In fact, Yunzhi had participated in the battle for the throne when Emperor Kangxi was still alive, so he had always been regarded as a thorn in Emperor Yongzheng's side. Soon after Yongzheng ascended the throne, he drove Yunzhi to the Eastern Tomb of the Qing Dynasty to guard the mausoleum of Emperor Kangxi. In the eighth year of Yongzheng's reign (1730), Yunzhi was deprived of his title and imprisoned in Yong'an Pavilion in Jingshan. He died in depression two years later.

In "Yongzheng Dynasty", Hongli (later Emperor Qianlong) wisely answered Emperor Kangxi's questions during the "Mulan Autumn Period" in the forty-sixth year of Kangxi, thus winning the favor of Emperor Kangxi. In real history, Hongli was only born in the 50th year of Kangxi. How could he participate in the "Mulan Autumn" in the 46th year of Kangxi.

The infantry commander Longkodo is the nephew of the important minister Tong Guowei in the play. In fact, Longkodo is Tong Guowei's third son. It is worth mentioning that Emperor Yongzheng did not grow up with his biological mother Wu Ya when he was a child, but was raised by Emperor Kangxi's imperial concubine Tong Jia (Queen Xiao Yiren), and Tong Jia was the daughter of Longkodo. Sister, so Emperor Yongzheng always called Uncle Longkodo.

In addition, there are some obvious errors in the play regarding the death time of Emperor Yongzheng’s biological mother, Wu Yashi, and the identity of Li Dequan, the eunuch beside Emperor Yongzheng. However, these errors are harmless and can be ignored if they are not too serious.