First of all, their purpose is not to rebel in order to overthrow the imperial power of the Song Dynasty, but to shout the slogan of "doing justice for heaven, killing the rich and helping the greedy", while doing the right thing for the government, eating and drinking in a big bowl, allowing is better than bandits. Thinking about prosperity in my heart and seeking personal revenge in my behavior, the pattern has been set in a small water margin. Throughout Song Jiang's life, he was loyal to the imperial power, full of loyalty, speculative but unsuccessful, kind-hearted but not soft. The end of Liangshan hero was decided at the beginning of your brother's admission!
In fact, Song Jiang's personal role is overestimated. Song Jiang is just a catalyst for the collapse of a class group. Song Jiang's class limitations and deep yearning and longing for feudal orthodoxy promoted the disintegration of the Water Margin Group. But sung river can subvert the whole Liangshan group by himself? Actually, it is not. Liangshan group has already had the subconscious mind of self-disintegration, and Song Jiang just lit a Mars.
If Liangshan heroes don't choose to woo, there will probably be two endings: one is to become another regime against the Northern Song Dynasty, divided into two factions, pulling forces and fighting for a long time until one side collapses. Second, the power continued to grow, eventually eliminating the Northern Song Dynasty and establishing a new feudal dynasty.
No matter what the ending is, the ideal kingdom of Liang Shanbo described by Shuihu, such as "a trip to the main road is the best in the world", "making the best of all talents" and "sharing weal and woe together", will collapse and become a dream blueprint hanging high in the void.
The reason why they dare to assert this is that they can never erase the feudal class brand in the depths of their souls and never break through the inherent feudal ideological cognition. This is the same as "entering the room of Lan Zhi, not smelling its fragrance for a long time; Don't smell it, it's the same thing to get into abalone. They were born in feudal society and immersed in the feudal imperial hierarchy all their lives. Without the sudden stimulation of fresh ideas that jump out of time and space, their ideological cognition is still exactly the same as the feudal ideological system, institutionalized and unified. This profound cognition was only covered up for a period of time by the anger of "officials forcing the people to rebel".
Secondly, the starting point for the heroes of the Water Margin to participate in the uprising is not self-conscious and introspective class progress, and their realm has not reached the height of truly establishing an ideal kingdom. Most heroes are "forced" to go to Liangshan, not voluntarily. This determines that their so-called "resistance" is weak and naive. Therefore, when the feudal orthodox class gave them a candy, the rebel group easily disintegrated.
The tragedy of Liangshan heroes has long been doomed. This vigorous uprising is nothing more than a child who has fallen out of favor.