This answer is simple and seems reasonable. Because once this slogan is realized and Emperor Qin Hui returns, where will Zhao Gou put himself?
Is this view correct? Wrong.
Indeed, at the beginning of his army, Yue Fei carried out the Northern Expedition under the slogan of welcoming the return of the two saints.
However, it should be pointed out that politically, it is absolutely correct to welcome the two saints back only at the beginning of the war, whether from the government or the people, or even Zhao Gou himself.
But since Shaoxing five years ago, Yue Fei has carefully combed and controlled his slogans and performances, and took the lead in renaming Er Sheng as "Tian Juan", just a relative of the emperor. So as to maintain a high degree of political consistency with Zhao Gou. Because two major events happened during this period:
One is this year, Song Huizong passed away.
Second, Wan Yanzong Bi is going to send Song Qinzong or Song Qinzong's son to Kaifeng to establish a puppet regime and create two Song States, with the intention of overthrowing the Zhao Gou regime.
In this case, welcoming back to "Tian Ju" is the best way to solve this crisis. The reason why Xu Jinguo has refused to release people is to use Qinzong as a bargaining chip and use it from time to time for political intimidation and blackmail. After Qin Zong died, he hid it from Zhao Gou for five years.
Therefore, many messengers begged Xu Jin to release Yue Fei's Zhao Gou, and would not kill him on the grounds of welcoming Yue Fei's early return.
The second point of view: Yue Fei suggested setting up a store, and the monarch and ministers were suspicious, which led to Yue Fei's death.
What are the reasons for supporting this view?
In the seventh year of Shaoxing, Yue Fei secretly discussed with Song Huizong to establish a prince. Zhao Gou's answer is: It's none of your business. Later, Yue Fei was despised by Prime Minister Zhao Ding.
This view used to be very popular, because it was sharp and professional, but it was also wrong.
It's true that Yue Fei put forward the suggestion of building a storage warehouse for Zhao, but it should be noted that this was not only put forward by Yue Fei, but also put forward by some people at the same time or even earlier.
Because the royal family has no family affairs, Li Chu is not only the family affairs of the Lao Zhao family, but also the state affairs of the country.
At that time, it was also faced with the problem that Jin Wushu wanted to launch the puppet regime established by former Prince Qin Zong. In this case, the establishment of Chu Jun is of great significance not only to stabilizing the people's hearts, but also to stabilizing the political platform.
What's more, Yue Fei proposed to set up a store on behalf of the military. This is because the military took a clear stand and stood firm: it did not recognize the former Prince Qin Zong who Xu Jin wanted to establish, but only recognized the Crown Prince established by Zhao Gou.
Smart as Zhao Gou, even if he is unhappy, he is not stupid. He won't do anything.
The third statement: the town is arrogant, but its tail is too big.
Objectively speaking, there is some truth: the four generals, together with the Wu brothers in Sichuan, took care of each other in money, food and politics, which objectively formed a situation in which five provinces were separated. This is unacceptable to Song Gaozong Zhao Gou, so he will try his best to get rid of Yue Fei.
However, this statement hardly constitutes murder: the existence of the five buffer zones is true, but it was based on the actual needs at that time and was formed under objective conditions. The existence of the five buffer zones is a powerful deterrent to Xu Jin.
The fact of depriving the three generals of their military power also proves that there are many ways to destroy the princes, and killing Yue Fei is not the only way. Moreover, before killing Yue Fei, he had basically deprived the three generals of their military power.
Even if you are afraid of Yue Fei's prestige in the army, there is no need to kill Yue Fei who voluntarily surrendered the relieving.
In a word, Yue Fei has given the Zhao and Song Wangs enough face in the matter of removing military power, which is not a fatal factor at all.
There is a fourth saying: Yue Fei is disobedient.
People who hold this view are mainly entangled in two things:
One is Yue Fei's filial piety. In the sixth year of Shaoxing, Zhang Jun impeached the fugitive general Liu Guangshi. Song Gaozong was going to hand over the army to Yue Fei, but he changed his mind halfway and handed over the military power to Wang De and Li Qiong (which led to the mutiny in Huaixi). In a rage, Yue Fei returned to Lushan to pay homage to his mother. Later, Song Gaozong Zhao Gou also said: I'm not angry. If I am angry, I will show my sword!
Second, Shaoxing's ten-year Northern Expedition recalled twelve Jin Yuefei.
This statement seems interesting at first glance. It's terrible that the heavily armed military commanders are disobedient. Miao and Liu Bing mutiny cast a shadow over them.
The question is, is this a fact?
First of all, the ministers of the Song Dynasty were disobedient, which was the characteristic of the Song Dynasty. Civil servants are disobedient and have always been famous for criticizing Longlin angrily. The result of reprimand and scolding is often promotion and wealth, fame and fortune; As for the disobedient military commanders, Liu Guangshi, Wu Jun and Zhang Jun, which is the obedient Lord?
Furthermore, is it objective to say that Yue Fei is disobedient? Twelve gold medals were called Yue Fei. Although he didn't want to, didn't Yue Fei go back? In contrast, people like Liu Qi and Wu Lin who insist on "I won't suffer for you all your life outside" won't care if you win a hundred gold medals.
Finally, when the three generals were deprived of military power, Yue Fei's performance was the most docile. He honestly wore the above clothes and went to the Privy Council on time and on time, which was a sign of obedience. How can you say that Yue Fei is disobedient?
Therefore, this reason does not hold water!
So what is the truth?
There is only one truth, that is, Zhao Gou's inner cowardice and fear, and at the same time, he showed his extreme desire for the stability of imperial power. Here, it is necessary to analyze the direct and deep reasons:
Let's look at the direct cause first:
Zhao Gou's killing Yue Fei is a realistic need, and it is also a realistic need for Song and Jin to make peace. For this matter, Wan Yanzong gnashed her teeth: "Kill Yue Fei, and then peace can be achieved."
For me, his only sense of security at this moment is not in himself at all, but comes from the extravagant hope of pity for the Jin people. The source of this extravagant hope is based on the century-long peace brought by the Song-Liao unit alliance. He thought that he could also achieve the centennial peace of Song and Jin through negotiations.
Then only kill Yue Fei, because as long as Yue Fei is such a staunch hawk, his peace will not be realized, and his imperial power will never be stable.
In order to secure the throne, Liu Yu's pseudo-qi-raising his hand to admit half of the country-can be abandoned or surrendered-can be done.
What? Finally kill another anti-gold faction Yue Fei? No problem.
To kill Yue Fei is to completely kill the warring factions and hand over the most valuable warlord to the Jin people: I would like to be a younger brother from now on, not a nephew.
Let's analyze it from the inside:
Throughout his life, he succeeded to the throne in anxiety and fled under the pressure of Jin people. His life is very rich, and he lacks everything except a sense of security. He was very afraid of the mutiny of military commanders with heavy weapons, especially Miao and Liu, which made him deeply afraid of military commanders.
More than ten years of imperial career did not make Zhao Gou smarter and braver, but made him more cruel and ruthless, and gradually grew into a top politician who was good at survival and grabbing.
Such an insecure politician doesn't trust military commanders at all, let alone Yue Fei. Zhao Jiudi's heart is not pleased with the brilliant achievements of Shaoxing's ten-year vigorous Northern Expedition, but afraid! He was afraid that Yue Fei would recover Henan and Hebei. Since then, this land is no longer surnamed Zhao. This is why Shaoxing recalled Zhang Jun and Wang De ten years ago, and recalled Yue Fei with twelve gold medals.
But it is not enough to recall Yue Fei, because Yue Fei is a god of war, an invincible god of war, and a rare god of war in a thousand years. Such a person, as long as he is alive, is a monument and a banner. As long as he climbs high, Henan and Hebei are still crowded and surging. In Zhao Gou's view, this once again threatened his throne, which was too scary and insecure!
Zhao Gou walked in fear and cowardice all his life, but he could never overcome his inner selfishness and cowardice. Instead, he listened to the devil's call!
After Yue Fei's death, Song was poisoned again, dismissed his men and completely split Yue Jiajun. What a waste of people and money!
So the physical destruction of Yue Fei is over? The answer is no! Song Gaozong and Zhao Gou destroyed all the records about Yue Fei's existence from the official to the folk. Strange men and men of courage like this god have never been "King's Landing" in this world. Once, you could only listen to and imagine Yue Fei and his Yue Jiajun through word of mouth. As a result, decades later, Yue Lei and York spent decades looking for Yue Fei's deeds and manuscripts, but some things were lost forever, which led to later generations' incomprehension and suspicion of Yue Fei's behavior, and some even speculated such a peerless hero with dirty hearts.
From body to spirit, he tried to completely eliminate the existence of a national hero, and all this was the result of the emperor's ultimate cultivation of art.
In fact, Emperor Zhao Gou has been in poor health for a long time. Now it's okay to make up a knife and complete the psychological palace.
However, the radiant light and dark clouds of the god of war can't stop it! When we calm down, clear the thick fog of history and re-examine this broken history with fearless heroic feelings, we can still see the monument of the God of War-forever majestic. Although Xiang Yu and Guan Yu were brave and skillful, they attacked their own nation and resolved internal contradictions. Yue Fei, living for saving the country and dying for loyalty cannot be overemphasized.
Today, we can see Guandi Temple all over China, and I hope that one day Yuefei's Zen Temple can also be seen everywhere. Because what kind of example this society respects, what kind of heroes may be born!