In my opinion, there are four reasons for the failure of anti-Qing logging: internal contradictions

1, Ming government: At that time, Emperor Hong Guang was incompetent and complacent, and Ma Shiying and Wei Zhongxian only took advantage of this to control the Ming government. Although it's not a big problem to hang the titles of University of Dongge and Minister of War, in fact, there are four towns on the north bank of the Yangtze River in the struggle against Shi Kefa in Qing Dynasty. They are arrogant and overbearing, and they also divide websites. Then how can we win the war army? On the occasion of the South Bowl, there were more serious contradictions within the Ming government. The power struggle between Zuo Liangyu and Ma Shiying was stationed in Wuchang, and SmithKline punished the generals of civil strife, so he had to return to Nanjing. The defeat of Zuo Liangyu, the governor of the Yangtze River and the general of the Ming army, undoubtedly reduced the morale and increased the fatigue of the Ming army, but more importantly, it gave Tomb-Sweeping Day a chance to prepare for a crushing defeat of the Qing army and lost an absolute opportunity! The disunity and infighting between the two generals in the Ming Dynasty were caused by the speed failure of the Ming army (politics).

2。 Ming 'an made a tactical mistake:! First of all, is it effective for the northern Ming government to arrange four towns along the Yangtze River? During the war, there were no reinforcements on both sides of the Yangtze River north of Sizhen, and there were few residents in Serenade, Yangzhou. So did it have any enemies? Then, when the neighboring provinces of Shandong people have begun to resist the Qing Dynasty, why not fight the Ming government and reinforce the people of Shandong Province? Why didn't they send some reinforcements at that time? Although you don't have to win, you took part in the battle that the people of Shandong can fight against the enemy, and the people of the whole country fought against the Qing Dynasty! People's private institutions can also reduce the pressure on the battlefield. Is it clear that it is waiting for a good opportunity to slip away from the United States (military)

At the age of 3, the Ming Dynasty itself was corrupt, and the government of the Ming Dynasty was even more corrupt: the incompetent and complacent Ming Emperor drank and had fun all day, and Shi Kefa even used Xing Meien, a senior official. As an old slogan, this slogan is not strong enough. Why? Because the old Ming Dynasty itself was corrupt, it didn't have the sympathy of the awakened people, but if China had a slogan for his national interests, I think his efforts would be much greater.

4, external forces are too strong, Ming did not hand over the provinces and other SAARC: At that time, there was no other joint anti-Qing regime in Ming and Southwest China, coupled with the strength of the Qing Dynasty, which made it more clear that Shi Ke punished the extinct regime for not resisting the Qing Dynasty (this is not an important reason)

To sum up, Shi Kefa led the troops tenacious, poor record. The events in China were set at this time. I don't know the time, but at this time, if people can win unity, Shi Kefa can't sit next to him. Regardless of the peasant uprising, in Yangzhou, on the edge of other bowls, people begin to gather. He is pale and bookish, unlike Yuan Chonghuan who led the troops to make bold moves, but not as good as Chang Yuchun who emphasized strategic mistakes, political and military mistakes, foreign mistakes, people who made mistakes, and mistakes in dealing with ethnic differences, which doomed SmithKline to be powerless. The disposal of Hong Guang's dissolute waste also accelerated the demise of Nanming. Shi Kefa didn't know that military was the continuation of politics or didn't attach importance to the connection between politics and military strategy, which was the root cause of failure!