I can understand you and support you ~ ~

The differences between Ming and Qing Dynasties are due to ethnic factors, but more importantly, the cultural differences ~ ~ ~ Yuan and Qing Dynasties are different from other great dynasties ~ ~ Especially the Qing Dynasty, which is actually a colony of the people ~ ~ so that the main job of the government is to make everyone think that the government is the people's government ~ ~ This can be distinguished by the Northern Wei Dynasty established by Yuan, Qing and Xianbei. Although the Northern Wei Dynasty was the government of different nationalities, it was the second unification and integration of China.

For the broad masses of people in the Qing empire, they are not so much subjects as tools to gather wealth ~ ~

Of course, the argument against the Ming empire is nothing more than that the people have ample food and clothing ~ ~ The prosperous period of the Qing Dynasty is the longest and the population is the largest ~ Adequate food and clothing is only basic. Have you ever seen a pig farmer who doesn't work hard? From the perspective of tax exploitation, the Qing dynasty will not be weaker than the Ming dynasty ~ ~ ~ But as far as socialist researchers are concerned, capitalist people live better than socialism, which proves that capitalism makes people live better. Evaluating whether a dynasty is advanced depends on whether the social ideological trend is positive and progressive, and whether it keeps pace with the times ~ ~ Only in this regard, the Qing Empire has never done it, but it just wants to maintain its abnormal political status ~

Due to the abundant food and clothing in the Qing Dynasty, the population disappeared in large numbers in the early Qing Dynasty for various reasons. The reason is well known ~ ~ ~ 2. The climate is getting better. 3. Large-scale popularization of American crops. The flourishing age of Qing dynasty is actually sweet potato ~ ~ There are opportunities in Ming dynasty, but any government may achieve this flourishing age ~ ~

Besides, the emperors of the Qing dynasty were all brilliant, better than the emperors of previous dynasties, but this was only in the emperor's mind and ability to control deception. Their essence is backward ~ ~ great politicians, which does not mean that they are recognized by mainstream values ~ ~ Hitler is also a great politician. What's his reputation?

It is important to look at the level of intellectuals in Ming and Qing Dynasties. Judging from the degree of openness, the Ming Dynasty undoubtedly did better. Although the upper emperor can influence the policy, the implementation is done by the main intellectuals ~ ~ The Han intellectuals in the Qing Empire did not find the main contradiction to the country at all ~ ~ The first sentence of Dr. Sun Yat-sen's slogan ~ ~ This is the most fundamental problem in 300 years ~ ~