Comments on orphan Zhao 1
I don't know why Chen Dao "tampered" with history, which has a bad influence on children's shoes. How to treat Zhao orphan/mosquito blood and seals? .
Don't use your head. It's much easier to get such a rich historical theme at your fingertips-why bother to please?
It's okay to change it well, but it's full of loopholes. How many fans regret it! Ha ha.
Not to mention that Duke Jing of Jin deserved to die, he would not be bitten to death by poisonous mosquitoes, and he would not die immediately.
What mosquitoes are so poisonous? It is more toxic than Heding Red/Qibu Powder and Arsenic. Netizens said it was the latest technology, hehe.
The auspicious symbol behind the neck is purely a seal. Where did this allusion come from? It's kind of like driving ducks to the shelves.
The enemy is at hand, and life and death are at stake. Zhuang Ji and Cheng Ying still lingered for so long. This clip should be fast-paced and short, so as to reflect the nervous mental state. Obviously, the ice-skating beauty should show more, otherwise such a big star will only show her face for a few minutes, which is too weak.
When she died, Cheng's wife should cry or shout out, surprised and surprised, but she didn't. She was abnormal.
Han Jue and Cheng Ying have had a late-night private meeting for more than ten years, but Tu'an Gu won't find out. He felt that a power as big as Tu'an Gu must have spies like Dongchang/Xichang.
The two of them really tied their lives to the little boy. It was careless.
Why didn't Cheng's wife give the child medicine to stop the child from crying?
How can Cheng Ying not let Wu Zhao study? This is not normal. He will not be allowed to worship Tu'an Gu as his adoptive father, because their looks can easily reveal their secrets. This is what ordinary people would think.
And Gongsun Chujiu is too young. Actually, he should be a 70-year-old man. It should be that Gong Sun asked how old he was and Cheng said he was 46. Gongsun said that she was 70 years old and had to die first, leaving Cheng to support orphans. Such an important role has been obliterated, leaving only such a small space for ZhangFeng yi to play. This is so unfair to the hero Gongsun Chujiu.
It was even more ridiculous later. Tu'an Gu was patient with Wu Zhao. He kept the father and son alive. How could the devil kill the tiger and put it back into the wild? When fighting, there were no servants, and they were still outside. And ridiculous.
Cheng Ying is a man, and Tu'an Gu has armor. However, Cheng Ying still lived for such a long time, but Tu'an Gu was killed on the spot, which is illogical.
Finally, Cheng Ying's image is disappointing. He didn't find a doctor, and he didn't get help. This is a long slow motion. What do you mean, silent, ending? As other netizens said, Zhao's orphan became Cheng's orphan.
Historically, monarchs and senior officials tricked Tu'an Gu into entering the palace and killed him. Scott's orphan attacked the official again, and Cheng Ying committed suicide (he said he was not dead), just like a painting.
On the other hand, what do you think of orphan Zhao/mosquito blood and seal? The Beijing opera Orphan of Zhao is more exciting than the movie. But orphan Zhao is better than other movies. After all, the most prominent thing is that Cheng Ying sacrificed his family for justice, and this theme is still clear.
All the actors didn't say anything, but they all acted very well. This time, it was more comfortable than Chen Hong, although her son played a small princess. Chen Hong's roles in The Promise and Mei Lanfang are really flattering, which makes the films pale.
Ge You's performance was great. He was quite big when he was young. Maybe he was so thin when he was old because he wore too many clothes. Like two people, I really doubt that his father is playing the old times. Ha ha.
The emperor played a special role, a bit like Dong Hao, and the temperament of a bad king was brought into full play.
Zhao's performance was ok, perhaps according to the director's requirements. I always feel that the performance is not bad enough, and it is a bit like a good person. The vision and sinister of the bad guys have not been brought into play. If there is a close-up of the eyes, the effect will be better.
The music of the whole computer is well coordinated, and it can score more than 90 points, but there is a female voice humming behind it, which is a bit disappointing. It's better to change the male voice. After all, it shows a man's elegance and heroism.
During the Spring Festival, I watched so many domestic movies, and the postmodern life of my aunt played by Gaowa Siqin and Chow Yun Fat was the best. The film was originally directed by Xu Anhua. Except Let the Bullets Fly and Golden Flower in the City, everything else is ridiculous, such as Promise/Mei Lanfang/especially the old man's Love of Hawthorn Tree, which is the worst one I have ever seen.
Compared with foreign film production, domestic films are really dwarfed. It's really much worse
I have also seen The Wind, If You Are the One, A Royal Guard, Mulan, The Gunner's King, Sword Rain, Banquet, world without thieves, Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon, Painted Skin, Love of Hawthorn Tree, Promise and Mei Lanfang.
The least attractive is Sword Rain, the most regrettable investment and production. Yang Ziqiong's performance is regrettable. The script is the worst.
Zhao's orphan review 2
Not long ago, I watched the movie Orphan of Zhao in the cinema, which was very touching. Today, some wonderful pictures in the film come to my mind from time to time.
This film tells the story that Zhao was framed in the Jin Dynasty, 300 people were killed, leaving only one orphan, who was adopted by a doctor, raised him and avenged his father.
This film depicts many flesh and blood characters, and two of them left a deep impression on me. One is Cheng Ying, and the other is Tu'an Gu.
Cheng Ying, doctor of Jin State. He is a person who can put the overall situation first and the interests of others first. At that time, Zhao was punished, and his wife was desperate and entrusted her son to die heroically. He took his son home, but when he came to Gongsun's house, the orphan Zhao was taken away by the officers and men sent. However, he remembered what his wife said before she died, so he went through all the hardships and finally rescued the orphan Zhao at the expense of his wife and children.
Sadly, he is bent on raising his children and avenging him. So he named the orphan Zhao and took him home as a guest. I wonder how much courage it takes. Under Tu'an Gu, he raised Cheng Bo with perseverance beyond ordinary people's imagination. In the end, "God helps those who help themselves" finally got what he deserved, and finally fell into the hands of the orphan Zhao. However, he paid his whole life and precious life for it.
Cheng Ying's spirit of putting the overall situation first touched thousands of Qian Qian audiences and also gave people profound enlightenment. Sima Qian once said: "People are inherently mortal or lighter than a feather or heavier than Mount Tai." If Cheng Ying's final fate is more important than Mount Tai, then if he fails to raise Scott's orphans, his death will be as light as a feather and insignificant.
We admire Cheng Ying's spirit, but we don't like Tu'an Gu's face.
Tu'an Gu, Minister of the State of Jin. But it is really "treacherous". Compared with Cao Cao of the Three Kingdoms, it is really "even worse"! In the film, Zhao drank the emperor's wine and took the opportunity to frame him, trying to destroy the Zhao family. Its wolf ambition is really scary! Even if the 300 people of the Zhao family were destroyed, he would not even let go of the orphans of the Zhao family, and he was determined to destroy the grass. However, in front of Cheng Ying, who takes the overall situation as the priority and protects the country at the expense of his family, he can only bow his head.
As the saying goes, "good is rewarded with good, and evil with evil. It's not that you don't report it, it's not time." Sure enough, fifteen years later, he finally got what he deserved and died by the sword of the orphan Zhao. It's really gratifying. People like Tu'an Gu were the dregs of society at that time. From him, I really understood a sentence of Liu Bei in the Three Kingdoms period: "Don't repay evil for good." Nowadays, as citizens and members of society, we should make more contributions to society and inject new vitality into society. Instead of doing bad things blindly, there is no kindness, no concern, no mutual help, no gratitude. That will only be like Tu'an Gu, spurned by people and become the scum of society.
Every movie is different, and every movie is thought-provoking. From The Orphan of Zhao, I understand the truth of being a man. He is like a bright lamp, illuminating my way forward. After watching this movie, my mood is still like a raging sea, and I can't calm down for a long time. Perhaps this is the unique charm of the film!
Reflection on orphan Zhao 3
After a tragic failure from the sky, Chen Kaige is much smarter and willing to bow his head, but his arrogance and aristocratic spirit are still there. No, look what he chose. First, a generation of perfect Mei Lanfang, and then a classic tragedy of China, which is quite close to the people without losing style. Compared with the Buddhists who cut corners, he is still a little careful. Only in "The Orphan of Zhao", when the high scores of female students floated out from the background, such as chanting and weeping, I felt as if I saw Chen Kaige caressing his chest and sighing-he was still closed in his own world, immersed in his own sense of tragedy and unable to extricate himself.
Looking at the New Year movies in recent years, orphan Zhao is certainly not a bad movie, but it is definitely not a good movie touted by some people, nor has it shocked the world or returned. Chen Kaige can make a touching big scene, like Zhao being wronged in court; You can order one or two demon supporting roles, such as the King of Jin and the counselor, but with these, he can only make one-third of the good movies, just like Mei Lanfang, so that you can enjoy a foreplay that goes straight to the climax. I didn't expect to stop at once and say Mr. Trouble will come again next time. What should be done is not finished, which is the biggest problem of orphan Zhao. This inevitable revenge is endless, just like a sigh of relief. It should be more infectious than the opening and the sense of the picture. Not to mention the serial assassination of three people, there is no suspense in the whole process of revenge, and it was played lightly, which ruined Ge You's humiliation for dozens of minutes before. Even if this point is removed and the out-of-body experience surreal ending is added, The Orphan of Zhao is still an unfinished drama, as if calling on everyone to watch the tragic fate, and the family is ruined. I thought of "With You" directly. A bunch of people were watching their children play the violin, which seemed sensational, but it was actually very artificial and melodramatic.
Moreover, several characters are untenable, not to mention the disfigured Huang Xiaoming. His hero Han Jue basically played an entertaining role, greatly diluting the tragic color of the film. I really don't know whether it's Chen Kaige's joke or Huang Xiaoming's self-motivation. Cheng Ying is the one who really can't stand up. Movies waste too much pen and ink on trivial matters of life. Because of his passivity, The Orphan of Zhao can never explain his real motives, let alone show the collapse of people. Due to Cheng Ying's restraint, Wu Zhao has been wavering. How did he know the truth and stab his adoptive father with a sword? All these are taken for granted. The logic given in the movie is this: Cheng Ying runs to Tu'an Gu, and Wu Zhao will naturally help Cheng Ying without any reason. This film is intended to continuously strengthen Wu Zhao's contradictory experience. He is an adoptive father as well as an adoptive father. He should have had a wonderful inner struggle, even self-defeating. And these have all disappeared in "The Orphan of Zhao", and there are many futile external fights, which basically fall short.
After all, The Orphan of Zhao is still a typical China blockbuster. You will have a similar experience of laughing, and you will have the illusion of passing through in an instant. Those film and television bases that can be seen at a glance, those dusty extras, and all kinds of loopholes that trample on historical facts. Therefore, The Orphan of Zhao did not completely transform Chen Kaige, let alone stand out in this era.
Reflections on Zhao's Orphan 4
The story of "Zhao's Orphan" was very famous in ancient China, but it was deliberately ignored after liberation, and the loyalty and faith it preached was thrown aside like our shoes. Knowing that someone is going to make a movie with huge investment, I look forward to the early release of this movie. I was busy on duty on Sunday for more than 20 hours. After I came back yesterday afternoon, I lay like mud for more than four hours, and my strength and spirit recovered. In the evening, it suddenly occurred to me that I could go to the movies alone. I checked the time in the hospital QQ group, and there is another one at 9: 50 pm. Go to Shiqiao at nine o'clock. When buying tickets, another man stood next to me waiting to buy tickets. I took out one hundred yuan (fifty yuan each) and said, "I want a ticket." Maybe I spoke in a low voice. The female conductor looked up at me and asked, "Do you want two tickets?" "Just one." I raised my right index finger and said in a loud voice. Can't young men watch movies alone?
Get down to business. As a New Year's card, The Orphan of Zhao was widely publicized by various media, and it also created a scandal that the young and the old matched Fan Bingbing, which was cruel enough. On the Internet, they all said they saw the first half of a good movie. I think this is biased. The first part tells the story of Zhao's killing, raising orphans and becoming orphans. The plot is thrilling and compact, and the scene is magnificent. The second one is more warm and tells the story of raising Zhao's orphans. In the end, there will be a horse battle, a less fierce decisive battle. The director wants to show warmth and humanity in the second half of the film. In the eyes of the so-called film critics on the Internet, the second half is a failure, indicating that the director has surpassed people's acceptance.
Cheng Ying took Zhao Gu as a guest (killing Zhao's enemy) and made Zhao Gu recognize that the thief was his father, while Tu'an Gu was michel platini. Violent, treacherous and vicious Tu'an Gu believes that he is really Cheng Ying's son, and teaches him martial arts and the truth of being a man. He is a father. Tu'an Gu found that his son Cheng Bo (the name of Zhao Gu in the play) was the only blood left in the Zhao family, and the extinction did not succeed. If you want to kill someone during the horse war, you can't bear it at the critical moment. Finally, when Wu Zhao (the real name of Zhao Gu in history) took Cheng Ying to the door for a duel, Tu'an Gu could kill a 15-year-old boy and an old and frail doctor with a few moves, but he couldn't bear it many times. Finally, when Tu'an Gu stabbed Cheng Ying, he was distracted and stabbed to death by Wu Zhao's sword. -This is the humanity that Director Chen Kaige tried to exaggerate. Wonderful and exciting, half a movie is enough. I think it is a civilized and progressive move for revenge movies to talk about human nature. Tiger poison does not eat children, and treacherous people are also affectionate with their fathers and sons. Those who exaggerate bloody violence are criticized, those who preach human nature are not wonderful enough, and the audience's appetite is too difficult to serve. Director Chen Kaige did not dare to obey the public in a commercial blockbuster, but stood in a high position to lead the public, which is also a kind of courage.
Tell the story according to history. During the Spring and Autumn Period, Zhong Er, the son of the State of Jin, lived in exile for 19 years, and finally became the monarch of the State of Jin with the help of the State of Qin. That is Jin Wengong, one of the famous "five tyrants in the Spring and Autumn Period". All the people who followed him for many years, except Jie Tui who was burned to death in Mianshan, were blocked, and Zhao Shuai was one of them. Since the decline of Zhao, the Zhao family has occupied a high position in the politics of Jin State, which is a starting point. With the development of history, Zhao's descendants finally participated in the "Three Points in Jin Dynasty" and established Zhao as one of the Seven Heroes in the Warring States Period. Although the story of "Zhao's orphan" is recorded in Historical Records, we can't believe it all. Many historical books before Historical Records are not recorded, and there are many discrepancies between the recorded people. There are many versions of The Orphan of Zhao. In The Orphan of Zhao in Yuan Dynasty, it is required to be considered as adoptive father, which shows that director Chen's version is similar to Ji's version. Ji's version is so famous that many people now say that director Chen's version has a "big adaptation", which is a bit far-fetched. The orphan of Zhao, Feng Menglong, A Brief History of the Eastern Zhou Dynasty, took him to the wilderness in the Ming Dynasty. An old man (the ancients lived a short life) took a child to hide in the barren hills. If you want to teach him cultural martial arts and help him revive the Zhao family, the possibility of success is extremely low. If Tu'an Gu, who lost his son, is adopted as an adoptive father, Zhao Gu will have a great chance to grow up and receive a good education. In addition, he will be more likely to use political struggle to revive Zhao in the future. Even from the perspective of the staggering plot and humiliating moral persuasion, Ji's version is worth learning from today's investors.
Ge You deserves to be the first brother of the actor in China's New Year film. He brought Cheng Ying back to life. Not all real heroes die by shouting slogans. He is a charlatan, even a little obscene. Originally he was an outsider, but he was entrusted as an orphan. He changed Zhao Gu into his own son intentionally or unintentionally. He watched helplessly as his son was thrown to death and his wife was stabbed to death. He has to bear the burden of humiliation, bring up Zhao Gu, and find a way to make Zhao Gu a member of the Zhao family and avenge Cheng Ying. Of course, it is to revive the Zhao family, which is not mentioned in the film. Cheng Ying's life is much more difficult than Gongsun Chujiu's death. Cheng Ying is a real hero! Ge You brought the hero to life, and he covered up the brilliance of Fan Bingbing and Huang Xiaoming. You must obey him, an old man in his fifties.
Finally, I want to say a word of disharmony. Or it doesn't matter to many people, but I hope readers of this blog post will understand. The film made a very serious historical mistake. It was impossible to have such a spectacular horse fight 2600 years ago! The reason is simple, stirrup has not been invented. Without stirrups, riding is very dangerous and painful, and you need to hold the horse with your legs. If you can't sit still, what can you talk about waving weapons on horseback? Zhao's "Riding and Shooting" has no stirrup, nor does Qin Shihuang's light cavalry, which can be seen from the Qin Terracotta Warriors and Horses. The hussars are more just riding on horses to achieve rapid progress. Historians are not sure when the stirrup was invented. To be sure, the stirrup appeared in the Eastern Jin Dynasty, while the stirrup appeared in the West in the early eighth century. There are three factors that determine the combat capability: mobility, aggression and defense. In the era of cold weapons, cavalry was the most powerful, so Mongols could kill all the way to Europe. In the era of hot weapons, the king of land war was a tank, and the air was a fighter. It is impossible for the producer not to know these historical common sense. I guess it is to cater to the audience. Might as well join Touma. But it is obviously misleading.
On the whole, The Orphan of Zhao is a good movie, which is worth seeing by car alone at night.
Review of Zhao orphans 5
At the end of the year, the unit held a 20 10 commendation meeting for party and government work, and prepared to show a film after the meeting to express condolences to the staff representatives attending the meeting, as in previous years. Several New Year films are being shown at present. I am not interested in entertainment films such as Fly 2, Let Bullets Fly and the legendary swordsman, so I decided to watch orphan Zhao with historical theme. The union contacted the cinema, which said it could not move the digital machinery and equipment to the venue. I also contacted the film company, and specially transferred a copy of orphan Zhao from the provincial film company, using an ordinary projector.
When the film screening was announced after the commendation meeting, the situation at the venue was strikingly similar to last year, and people left one after another. There are nearly a thousand people at the meeting, and the rest are definitely not more than one hundred. The leaders were so embarrassed that they vowed never to go to the movies again. I don't know why, but the rented venue of Angang Staff Cultural Center was very cold, and some people were frozen away during the film screening. It is too cold to sit there. I stood at the back of the venue, smoking a cigarette, walking around, as if watching an open-air movie in a rural youth spot. Fortunately, when people are cold, they are particularly energetic, feel particularly awake, and are particularly impressed by the film.
The main idea of the movie "The Orphan of Zhao" is that during the Spring and Autumn Period, Zhao Shuo, a general of the State of Jin, made outstanding achievements in military service. His father was the prime minister and his wife was the sister of the monarch. Zhao's position and prestige are prominent, and he is jealous of treacherous court officials. Tu'an Gu took advantage of the opportunity of Duke Jing of Jin to celebrate Zhao Shuo's success and planned to kill more than 300 people of Zhao's family for the crime of regicide. Zhao Shuo's wife Zhuang Ji gave birth to her son just at this time. Before committing suicide, she entrusted Cheng Ying, the doctor who delivered her baby, with the help of Han Jue, who was ordered to kill Zhuang Ji's mother and son, to rescue the baby in the medicine box. Zhao's orphan was taken away in the city search. And his wife, with the help of Zhao's good friend doctor Gongsun, designed to exchange their son for Zhao's orphans, and their wife and Gongsun were killed. Cheng Ying was accepted as a guest of honor by Tu'an Gu, raised Cheng Bo, an orphan of Scott, under the nose of Tu'an Gu, and made Cheng Bo recognize Tu'an Gu as a martial art and learn from michel platini. Fifteen years later, the range wavelength became larger. Knowing the truth, he killed Tu'an Gu and avenged the Zhao family. Cheng Ying was also killed.
According to Sima Qian's Historical Records of Zhao Family, during the Spring and Autumn Period, the Zhao Shuo family, a powerful minister of the State of Jin, was exterminated in the third year of Emperor Jinjing (597 BC). The posthumous son survived under the protection of his disciples, Gong Sunhe, and later relied on Han Zeng and others to help Zhao Fuxing.
In my opinion, the paragraph about the orphan of Zhao in Historical Records is concrete and narrative, which is more like a legend than a historian's handwriting. Historically, various classical dramas adapted from this have been widely circulated and almost become household names. Orphan of China was adapted by Voltaire, a great French writer, and spread to the west. This time, it is undoubtedly a good thing that Chen Kaige and Chen Hong adapted this classic story of ancient China into a movie.
On the whole, Orphan of Zhao is a better remake. Director Chen Kaige is good at shooting historical films, and historical feature films such as Jing Ke Stabbed the King of Qin, Farewell My Concubine, Mei Lanfang and Founding the People's Republic have certain influence. At a time when entertainment films are popular and people blindly pursue vulgar culture, compared with Bullets Fly, Orphan of Zhao gives people a refreshing feeling.
Of course, the film also has shortcomings, that is, people are generally concerned about how to be faithful to the original. In The Orphan of Zhao, it is Zhao's guest and courtier. The theme style of the original work is: loyal subjects, good people, eliminating rape and punishing evil, and Zhao orphans being rehabilitated. It's amazing to read. However, Cheng Ying in the film has become an outsider in the political struggle. He was forced to get involved and made great sacrifices. The motivation of raising Zhao orphan 15 years is to wish him dead. The film adapted historical allusions with obvious classical heroism into tragic stories reflecting the sadness and helplessness of little people in troubled times. This is superfluous and greatly weakens the artistic appeal of the story. Reminiscent of some films made by Chen Kaige, it always gives people a feeling that they are too talented to live a high life. The reason is worth pondering.