In 2006, Wang Hao, a judge in the Nanjing Peng Yu case, famously said, "You missed. Why do you want to help it? " This sentence triggered a public discussion and controversy about the Peng Yu case.
What this sentence means is that if the person who was knocked down didn't take the initiative to ask for help, then why should he help them? This problem has aroused people's debate about whether to help the elderly. Some people think that there is no need to help him if he doesn't hit the man himself. This is a moral responsibility and obligation.
Others think that if you don't bump into someone yourself, then helping is also out of kindness and compassion, which is also a manifestation of social morality.
This problem also reflects the contradiction and conflict between morality and law in today's society. In modern society, people's awareness and pursuit of morality and responsibility are getting higher and higher, but at the same time they are faced with many moral and legal problems. In this context, the law needs to define the standards of liability and compensation more clearly, and at the same time, it needs to pay more attention to and protect moral and ethical values.
At the same time, moral and ethical values also need more attention and publicity to guide people to pay more attention to conscience and responsibility in their behavior and follow fairness and justice.
The whole story of Nanjing Peng Yu case;
Peng Yu case refers to the civil litigation case that caused great controversy on the morning of1October 20th, 2006, 165438. Xu Shoulan, an old man, was knocked down and fractured at a bus stop in Shuiximen Square. Xu Shoulan recognized the attacker as Peng Yu, a young man who just got off the bus, but Peng Yu denied it.
On October 20th, 2006/KLOC-0, at about 9: 30 am, Xu Shoulan was hit by Peng Yu while catching a bus and went to the hospital for examination. However, Peng Yu, who accompanied her to the hospital, denied that she had hit Xu Shoulan, so Xu Shoulan took Peng Yu to court.
At the time of the incident, there was a statement record of the collision between the two sides in the police interrogation record. However, this transcript was accidentally lost by the police station in the city where the police were received.
Because of this, Peng Yu insisted on the "collision-free" defense in future court trials, and took the initiative to call the moderator of a website forum, saying that he was falsely accused of doing good deeds and was helping an old lady and queen mother to be sued. I hope the media will pay attention to this matter. The host immediately informed more than a dozen media and website reporters in Nanjing that there was improper hype that deviated from the truth and misled the public.
Liu Zhiwei, then member of the Standing Committee of Nanjing Municipal Committee and secretary of the Municipal Political and Legal Committee, pointed out in an exclusive interview with reporters in June 20 12: "Regarding the mediation result, Peng Yu also said that Xu Shoulan did collide with him in the accident that occurred in June 010, 2006. After mediation by the court, he expressed satisfaction with the result. " ?