Judge's self-evaluation article 1
Time flies, I will be in the Gulou court for three months. During the period, I took the dean's high hopes for the assistant judge, adhered to the teaching of "coming safely" and worked as an assistant with the judges in the criminal court, which benefited a lot. No matter in working attitude, or in all aspects of ability, has been greatly improved; At the same time, I also saw many shortcomings of myself.
"Attitude determines everything, attitude determines height", especially in work, we must be modest and prudent, guard against arrogance and rashness, and be practical and serious, so that we can quickly integrate into work and really learn some knowledge. I remember when I first came here, I thought I had accumulated a lot of practical experience in the Nanjing Drum Tower Court and felt that I could do some simple things, but this separated the relationship between universality and particularity. Every place is different to some extent, and I made some mistakes. I am grateful to the guidance judge for his strict teaching of my work, which made me wake up in time and get on the right track. From then on, I studied hard and developed the character of asking if I don't understand, and I didn't know how to go to school. So I am very grateful to my guidance judge, who made me deeply understand the importance of attitude and benefited me for life.
On the basis of correct working attitude, my ability in all aspects has also been improved. Mainly in the following aspects:
First, review the marks.
The content of marking includes evidence volume and litigation volume. At present, it is mainly to review procedural issues, try to avoid procedural injustice and provide guarantee for realizing substantive justice. Through the guidance of judges and their own identification, the problems that are easy to appear in procedures and entities mainly include the following aspects:
First, it is unacceptable that the same person appears in the interrogation record and the interrogation record or the identification record at the same time. If such a problem only occurs between interrogation transcripts, it can be confirmed by other interrogation transcripts or evidence, which is also ascertainable.
Second, there is a lack of some evidence materials, such as recidivism, commutation and other evidence materials; No invoice will affect the determination of the amount of crime, and so on, affecting sentencing.
The third is the contradiction between evidences, such as the contradiction between the amount on the invoice provided by the victim and the appraisal price; The defendant's confession is different from the victim's statement, mainly in the amount of crime; The difference between the defendant's statement and the witness's testimony is mostly about the difference of the crime amount, which will affect the determination of the defendant's crime amount.
At the same time, I also saw my own shortcomings in marking papers. At present, my ability is still limited, and the identification of entities needs to be improved. The ability to control the whole case needs to be improved. I hope that through my own efforts, I can further improve my ability in this field, be better qualified for my work and solve problems for judges.
Second, communication and coordination.
At work, there are many places that need communication and coordination. Although you don't understand, ask, but everyone has their own role and work to be busy, unless there is no other better way to hurry, then ask for advice humbly. I think the most important thing is that you don't know how to go to school. Observe and think more, and you will gain something. During this period, this assessment has the following aspects:
1。 Get along with the judge and determine twelve words: flexible and careful, diligent and practical, and strict with yourself. Influenced by the guiding judge, I have gradually been strict with myself in my work, being serious and focused, being flexible when things happen, and not fighting unprepared battles. All roads lead to Rome. If you encounter problems, try to solve them through other channels. A judge's assistant assists the judge and
It's not to trouble the judge, what's more, my guidance judge has been working hard and taking care of me like this. What I can do now is to work hard and do good deeds. "It is better to teach people to fish than to teach them to fish", and the guiding judge taught me how to solve problems, which benefited me a lot more than helping me solve many things, so I was very lucky.
2。 When dealing with others in this court, pay attention to four words: communication and kindness. Actively do everything told by the judge and the back office, and try not to make mistakes; Where there is a need, as long as you can do it yourself, you must work hard to do it well; Coordinate with back office and clerks to prevent defects and affect the quality of cases.
3。 The relationship with the staff of the procuratorate and public security organs is also determined in eight words: preparation in advance, coordination and cooperation. Because of the particularity of the court's work, it is particularly important to coordinate with the public prosecution and act flexibly; Of course, handling the relationship well and making preparations in advance will get twice the result with half the effort. At the same time, pay attention to check the identity of visitors, audit documents and procedures.
4。 Stay with defenders, parties and others, pay attention to the legal issues of qualifications and procedures, understand the turnover of things, and do your own job well. If it is a defender, notify him to complete the entrustment procedures or other relevant materials; If requested by the victim, it shall be improvised; If the defendant's family asks for a meeting, it depends first on whether the judgment has an appeal period or whether the co-defendant appeals, and then on the delivery of the closing form. Only when the meeting conditions are met can they be given a notice of admission to prison, and each defendant will only give one copy and sign the receipt.
5。 Other matters needing attention: the service receipt must be signed before filing the case, and when the document is served to the defendant, it should be signed and fingerprinted, and an interrogation record should be made; Pay attention to some details when sentencing, sign the sentencing record, indicate the time, and press fingerprints in many places; Files are classified and filed according to year number, public security volume (including evidence volume, litigation volume) and procuratorial volume.
When adjusting the volume, search the volume, the positive volume and the attached volume according to the rules; When closing the case, it must be accompanied by the judgment and the defendant's receipt of service, as well as the subsequent transcripts of court hearings and inquiries; Distinguish between the notice of appearance to the defender and the notice of appearance to the procuratorate.
Although there is a certain knowledge of communication and coordination in all aspects, there are still many aspects that are not in place and need to be involved and studied in depth. I should still keep a modest, cautious and positive attitude.
Three. Drafting legal documents
After reviewing the papers, I entered the stage of drafting legal documents. In order to adapt to the judge's style and standardize the legal documents as soon as possible, I drafted the documents by studying the legal documents made by the judge before. During identification, the following aspects should be paid attention to:
1。 The writing is standard and the format is correct. As the most important legal document, the judgment is the most important link to reflect the appearance of the court. The correctness of its format and the standardization of its writing are particularly important. Sentences should be fluent, clear and free of typos.
2。 The language is standardized and the details are appropriate. The judgment is concise, but the content should be fully reflected, so when writing the judgment, it should be concise and appropriate. Where the facts are clear and indisputable, you can abbreviate them; For complex facts, controversial or important controversial focus, it is necessary to write in detail. At the same time, we should pay attention to the professionalism and standardization of language.
3。 Pay attention to details and be careful. On the one hand, it is not only the need of doing things for people, but also the need of legal documents. A judgment, to cover all the contents, must involve many details. Any omission or mistake may affect the effectiveness of the judgment and damage the credibility of the court. Therefore, when writing legal documents, we should pay special attention to details.
Such as the format of the text of the judgment; You can't leave out people who appear in court; The time, place and characters of the crime must not be wrong, and so on.
4。 Strict logic and careful thinking. If the correct format and standard sentence expression are the appearance of the judgment, then the logical rigor is the blood of the judgment, which runs through the whole judgment. At present, there is only a superficial understanding of this, and more study and training are needed in the future, which is a necessary condition for a qualified legal professional.
To sum up, under the guidance of the judge, after three months of immediate study, I quickly adapted to the working rhythm of the court, and both legal theory and legal practice have been greatly improved. At the same time, I also found many shortcomings of myself. I need further understanding and exploration, and strive to enrich my knowledge and practical experience in order to better assist Wang Ting in handling cases.
Judge's self-evaluation II
In _ _ _, under the extensive attention and supervision of the district committee, the superior court, the National People's Congress, the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference and leaders from all walks of life, under the leadership of the president, through the joint efforts of the majority of judges and other police officers, as well as the cooperation and help of various organs and departments, the filing and civil trial work in charge of me has been smoothly promoted along the predetermined reform goal: the diversified dispute resolution mechanism has been further consolidated and improved. Litigation cases, enforcement cases, appeal cases and reform cases have maintained a stable trend after the sharp drop in _ _ _ _ _, and the number of new cases has been greatly reduced, which has rapidly promoted the professionalization of judges, actively created a good judicial environment, and significantly improved the work quality of people's courts. Most of the corresponding trial work indicators have remained in the forefront of the region, making due contributions to social stability, harmony and economic development. The Central Political Commissar, the Supreme People's Court, the Provincial Political and Legal Committee, the Provincial Higher People's Court, the Municipal Intermediate People's Court and the leaders of the district committees spoke highly of and affirmed the experience of _ _ multi-mediation. In particular, the theoretical results and practical effects of the court's "multiple mediation attached to the court" have won wide praise from Chinese and foreign experts, practitioners and judicial sessions.
I. Work performance
In addition to performing the duties of trial management, team management, government affairs management, party group and audit Committee in charge of the business court, the following work has been expanded:
1. Actively explore and practice diversified dispute resolution mechanisms, and achieved unprecedented results in the whole country, thus driving the work of the whole hospital into a brand-new historical stage.
In, the court was designated by the Supreme People's Court as "EU- United Nations Development Programme pilot court for judicial cost and efficiency" and "pilot court for judicial openness". 18- 19 In August, Dean Ma Xueyan and I participated in the demonstration meeting and writing division meeting of the social science fund project "Exploring Effective Ways of Judicial Efficiency Reform" and the EU- United Nations Development Programme project "Guide to Improving Judicial Efficiency" declared by the Supreme Court, and were identified as one of the eight authors.
These are all the Supreme People's Court's full affirmation of _ _ experience.
Through the investigation, comparison and understanding of various channels of advanced courts in other regions, our diversified mediation work is far ahead of other domestic courts in theory and effect.
2. Continue to promote the professionalization of judges.
First of all, through multiple mediation and diversion of complexity and simplification, the difficulty of hearing cases in commercial courts is improved and the natural optimization of civil and commercial judges is promoted. Since the beginning of this year, other organs and higher authorities have "selected" eight civil and commercial judges, accounting for 25% of the first-line trial judges. However, due to the structural optimization of the court and the requirements of the professionalization of litigation cases, the professionalization level of the courts in our hospital has not decreased, and we still adhere to the road of "a few elite judges try a few difficult cases". Under the background of difficult judicial environment, civil and commercial judges have successfully completed their trial tasks.
Secondly, we will continue to adhere to the formal collegiate bench system, the system of pre-trial discussion of cases, the system of sentencing in court and the system of answering questions after judgment, and strengthen the system of public trial of referee theory. On the basis of the system, build a platform for professional judges.
Third, continue to play the role of the Judicial Society. The publication of the bimonthly "Trial", the forum for judges held every Wednesday afternoon, and the Judicial Institute are operating normally. It not only solved some difficult cases and some legal frontier problems, but also formed a strong academic atmosphere, good working atmosphere and good atmosphere in the whole hospital.
Fourth, strengthen management. The first is trial management. This year, the innovation of collegiate bench system has been deepened, and the "sunshine trial" system has been implemented, such as pre-trial meeting, social discussion at trial, sentencing in court, answering questions after judgment, and strengthening referee theory.
The second is team management. In the past year, not a single policeman broke the law.
The third is government management. While coordinating the business cooperation and logistics support of related courtrooms, it is strictly required to be responsible for the government affairs management of courtrooms. It is forbidden to take charge of the court, sponsor, set up a small vault and other illegal and disciplinary acts.
3. The independent optimization and innovation of the trial environment have achieved good results.
First of all, through the publicity of the court work website of our hospital, we will establish a platform for communication and work. Secondly, with the Judicial Society as the main body, we should establish close cooperative relations with Beihua University, including establishing student practice bases, sending professionals to give special lectures, applying for scientific research projects, etc., so as to realize the complementary advantages of legal resources.
Third, create a legal person. First of all, we will join hands with Beihua University to establish a student internship base, invite lectures, research and development projects and academic exchange activities based on the Judicial Society. Followed by judges, lawyers, legal workers, corporate legal advisers, etc. of higher courts. He was invited to visit and exchange in the hospital to strengthen mutual communication and understanding, especially for the new problems brought about by the redistribution of judicial resources and the intentional break of interest balance in the reform of multi-mediation, which gained extensive understanding and support. The fourth is to organize some judges of the court to go into enterprises, military camps, communities and towns after the trial, and carry out publicity activities on popularizing the law and reforming through roving trials.
4, people-oriented, the establishment of service facilities
Legal aid window (and services such as remote compulsory legal consultation by lawyers in legal aid center), litigation process consultation window and multi-mediation consultation window have been set up in the filing hall and multi-mediation hall, and set up
Set up litigation guidance services, and set up touch screen, pre-litigation prompt bar, newspaper reading, rest seats and other services.
5. Self-construction
(1) was rated as an expert judge in Jilin Province by the Provincial High Court.
(2) Participate in the writing of the social science fund project "Exploring Effective Ways of Judicial Efficiency Reform" and the EU- United Nations Development Programme project "Guide to Improving Judicial Efficiency"
Two. Problems and future plans
First of all, many measures in the process of promoting the professionalization of judges are not in place. The reasons are as follows: on the one hand, some measures are originally pragmatic in order to settle for the second best; On the other hand, the theoretical quality, legal quality and professional ethics of new judges are very high, but the cultivation of legal awareness and the accumulation of legal experience cannot be achieved overnight, so the system of sentencing in court cannot be fully implemented immediately.
Secondly, the evaluation of pluralistic mediation needs to be further deepened. Mainly because of the personal experience of the appraisal experience, the appraiser must understand the reform and the essence of the reform, but at present, such a writing team has not been organized.
Third, in many aspects of external relations, it has not been put in place. On the one hand, the reasons are limited personal energy and limited court resources. On the other hand, the work of quitting the club is not paid enough attention.
Fourth, the specific measures of judicial openness need to be further deepened and implemented daily.
Fifth, judicial services need to be further improved. For example, the construction of legal aid window. In the future, the focus of work is to further implement it, and the work should be combined with reality.
First of all, the specific guidance and investigation of pluralistic mediation organizations need further discussion. After the civil trial in this hospital is on the right track, we will further improve the convenience litigation and diversified dispute resolution mechanism, and strive to play a role in the shortest possible time. At the same time, the trial work has changed to extended trial service, so as to improve the quality of trial work, improve the efficiency of trial work and expand the social effect of trial.
Secondly, the evaluation and discussion of diversified dispute settlement mechanism should be carried out as soon as possible.
Third, explore new modes of judge management, such as intensive management mechanism for judges. The implementation of sunshine trial needs the innovation of management facilities and mechanisms. Intensive management should be a beneficial attempt to save judicial resources, improve work efficiency and improve trial quality.
Fourth, strengthen academic discussion. At present, new disputes are constantly emerging and legal knowledge is constantly being updated. Therefore, in order to meet the needs of future trial work, we must take precautions, strengthen study and discussion, adapt to the future, and create conditions for judges to be further independent.
The future work is complicated. In short, in the future work, we must strengthen political and professional study, improve our judicial ability, make positive progress, redouble our efforts, faithfully perform our duties, strive for the upper reaches, accomplish the tasks entrusted to me by the party and the people brilliantly, and never disappoint their trust.
Article 3 of the judge's self-evaluation
As a law student, I love my major. The internship of the Third People's Court of Nanchong Intermediate People's Court ended, and now I make the following self-evaluation on this internship.
First, in the internship attitude, I have a correct internship attitude, respect for the leaders of the unit, respect for the staff of all positions in the unit, honesty and sureness, serious and responsible, study hard, keep making progress, and show strong enthusiasm and initiative for the work of the court.
Second, in terms of practice discipline, I should strictly follow the requirements of a preparatory party member, strictly abide by national laws and regulations, consciously abide by the rules and regulations of court work, not be late for work, not leave early after work, form a scientific and regular schedule, and ensure work efficiency.
Thirdly, in terms of internship ability, my practical work ability and work experience have been greatly improved and expanded from scratch, from point to point, by guiding the judges to explain and guide carefully and patiently, and by studying and understanding hard.
During my internship, I participated in some detailed and specific work, such as auditing the trial, sorting out the files, tracking the judges' out-of-court investigation, interviewing the parties, assisting in recording mediation and court transcripts, participating in the collegial panel's deliberation, and making and proofreading legal documents. , and independently complete other tasks assigned by our hospital.
Through conscious exercise and exercise in practical work, my basic ability of finding, analyzing and solving problems has been further strengthened, my basic ability of official document writing, language expression and communication has been further consolidated, my advanced ability of innovation and cooperation has been further optimized, and my social interaction and activity ability has been further improved.
Fourthly, as far as the internship effect is concerned, on the whole, I can turn what I have learned in school into my ability and experience in practical work, but there are also some defects and deficiencies that need to be improved.
Through internship, I learned about the whole process of court accepting and hearing cases and the procedures and steps of court work, which deepened my understanding of court work; Be able to master and apply the theoretical knowledge of law initially and guide the practical work scientifically; Improve personal quality and ability, develop ability, and further improve comprehensive quality. I have learned the basic knowledge of scientific document archives management, cultivated certain practical skills and can skillfully use modern office equipment.
Judge's self-evaluation Article 4
First of all, literacy
Several classes of this training focus on judges' professional ethics, judicial core values and judicial value system. Teachers' teaching content involves the ethics required by the judge's profession. "In the west, if a person is a judge, there is no need to consider that person's morality. Judges and virtuous people can be equated, but in our country, I'm afraid not, so we may not only have our simple legal knowledge and skills, but a quality (tolerance, kindness, fraternity, integrity, etc. That is higher than ordinary people should have, and these are the cornerstones of other skills. " As the saying goes, "the righteous use evil laws, and their laws are right, and the wicked use positive laws, and their laws are evil"! Judges need to have moral and material qualities!
Second, responsibility.
Every time we talk about the image of the western goddess of justice, we are deeply moved, but what many colleagues will have in the future is the right to life and death. Why do we advocate the rule of law but dare not pursue it? But why do so many colleagues desecrate the dignity of the law and the prestige of the judge profession? In these classes, the last thing students want is these pure legal concepts rather than practical courses. But I feel a little puzzled that although these students all want to get social respect and recognition in the industry, they often slander the public image of the judge industry in front of others. After this training, I also understand why the public is biased and puzzled about our industry. More often, we describe ourselves as such an image. Who can blame? If you don't protect your dignity, no one will protect you. These words came from their mouths, and there was no fairness and justice in the court. Sometimes it's really hard. If I say it from the mouths of ordinary people, I can understand them. But when I say them from my own population, I dare not look forward to the future of the rule of law.
Third, value.
Judges need to have their own value judgments. This kind of judgment needs the law first, which is more often reflected not only in your overall judgment of the law, but also in your judgment of the political, economic and social situation. Just pursuing a legal effect, the judge who adjudicates cases mechanically is just a legal tool. Is a judge who doesn't understand the art of law. I used to understand that the law should be independent. From that day on, I finally understood why the court's decision can't be divorced from politics, society and people's legal consciousness. "Law is a derivative of politics, how can it be divorced from politics? The law is for those in power. " Laws often need to maintain the stability and order of a society. Without stability, there will be no development, and the people will suffer in the end. How many people will pay the price for a judgment, and what kind of value orientation will society have. This is what we judges need to consider, not only the legal effect, but also the political effect. Teacher Dai Hai is right: Judges are not only jurists, but also politicians.
Fourth, wisdom.
Judges need wisdom, legal wisdom, political wisdom and, more importantly, folk wisdom. The case will only be submitted to the court after it has happened. What the judge needs is to restore the objective truth with evidence. The gap between objective facts and legal facts requires us to reason with the empirical rules of life. This is the wisdom we have accumulated in our daily life. Eliminate reasonable doubt. Restore the truth.
Judge's Self-evaluation Chapter 5
In the training of reserve judges, the lecturers carefully prepare lessons, covering the theory and practice of civil, criminal and administrative trials. They not only deeply explain and discuss the current judicial reform, but also have unique opinions on the construction of a clean government and team. During this period of intensive training, I strictly observed the training discipline, and benefited a lot from the process of listening attentively and was deeply inspired. It laid a solid foundation for how to be a good judge in the future and pointed out the direction.
Ideologically, legal beliefs are more firm. The law must be believed, otherwise it is useless. The teacher warned us that as reserve judges, we must believe in the law, because only the parties can be convinced of the judgment made according to the law; At the same time, "the law without faith will become a rigid rule, and the faith without law will become a crazy belief". We should not blindly believe in the law and interpret it dogmatically. Instead, we should judge according to the specific facts of the case, rely on common sense, common sense and common sense, choose the clauses that best reflect the value of fairness and justice from relevant laws, and make the due judgment results. At the same time, we should improve our ability to resist corruption and change, resist all kinds of temptations, be strict with ourselves and have a "zero tolerance" attitude towards corruption, otherwise we will be ruined and nailed to the column of shame of sin.
In learning, professional skills are stored in the brain. Confucius said, "If a worker wants to do a good job, he must sharpen his tools first." . This training is specially designed for observing civil, criminal and administrative court trials. Let's learn how the judge examines the evidence submitted by the parties to find out the objective facts of the case and how to accurately follow the law according to the established facts, which requires the judge to be effective. On the one hand, in the face of a huge and rapidly updated legal system, we must strengthen our familiarity and understanding of legal provisions, so as to be neither arrogant nor impetuous, and make preparations for realizing substantive justice. On the other hand, we also need to pay attention to maintaining dignity and neutrality in the trial, so that the parties can see the formal justice. In addition, the course of judicial etiquette also taught us that when we receive the parties, we should be reasonable and try our best to make them stop complaining and close the case.
As a reserve judge who is about to step into the trial post, I should have a firm legal belief, cultivate a solid theoretical foundation of law, master superb trial skills, be fair, honest and self-disciplined in trial practice, and strive to make the people feel fair and just in every judicial case they participate in.
Five self-evaluations of judges' work;
★ Self-evaluation of judges: 5 articles 1000 words or more.
★ Judge's work self-evaluation
★ Judge's professional ability self-evaluation
★ Five templates for police internship self-appraisal.
★ 5 articles on self-evaluation in work practice
★ Five practical self-evaluation articles during the internship.
★ Five self-evaluations of college graduates at the end of the term
★ Self-evaluation of reserve judges 20 18