Current location - Quotes Website - Excellent quotations - What kind of person is Xiang Yu in real history? Some people say that he loves soldiers like children, others say that he is cruel and bloodthirsty. What is Xiang Yu's true character?
What kind of person is Xiang Yu in real history? Some people say that he loves soldiers like children, others say that he is cruel and bloodthirsty. What is Xiang Yu's true character?
I. Commendable aspects:

1, affectionate and great husband

When Xiang Yu was trapped in Gaixia, he sang Long song and wept bitterly, leaving behind a song of Gaixia that has been told through the ages. The hero's battle on the battlefield is admirable, and the hero's tears cannot be taken lightly. Xiang Yu's tears made him cry, and he dared not look up. Later generations cried when they read this. As Zheng Banqiao sighed: "Why do heroes, horses and beauties all cry after crossing the Wujiang River?" Compared with Liu Bang's ruthlessness in pushing his children under the car in order to escape, Xiang Yu is a great husband and a tough guy with humanity.

2. The first episode of Beggar Hero

"I have played more than 70 battles since I was eight years old. I collapsed when I was caught and was taken away by the attacker. Never lost, and then dominated the world. But now I'm stuck here. My death today is not a war crime. I am willing to fight for you, and I will win three times. " This passage not only shows that Xiang Yu is brave and good at fighting, but also all-powerful. At the same time, we also see his self-confidence and self-love. Seeing this, why not remind people of "he can occupy the place!" Extraordinary spirit? Why not remind people of his heroic attitude in the battle of stag and the invincible momentum of Peng Cheng?

3. An honest and open-minded man

Director Wujiang Pavilion wants to ferry him to the east, saying that there are still 100,000 people in Chu, which is enough to make a comeback. Xiang Yu smiled and said, "What can I do if the sky dies? Besides, 8,000 people crossed the river to the west with Jiangdong's children, and none of them came back today. Longitudinal jiangdong father and brother pity and king me. How can I tell! If you say nothing, is a person worth it? " "I know the elders. I rode this horse when I was five years old ... I couldn't bear to kill it for the public. " Xiang Yu's frankness, generosity, honesty and kindness can't bear to show incisively and vividly. He would rather die generously and tragically than live in humiliation and shame. As sighed: "Why is Xiang Wang the son of heaven? It's just a quick decision. "

Second, Xiang Yu's character has extremely serious defects.

1, short-sighted, complacent, foolhardy and lacking in tolerance.

Xiang Yu's character has very serious defects: he is ambitious and supercilious; Love vanity, there is no lack of self-satisfied small-scale peasant consciousness; Everything is brave first, wisdom is behind, cruelty is more than enough, and kindness is not enough; Lack of advice, magnanimous monarchy. This decided his life. He should be just an all-powerful general, but he has no emperor's mind. His real mistake is not whether he killed Liu Bang, but his weakness. Even if he killed Liu Bang at the Hongmen banquet, he would be defeated by Zhang Bang, Wang Bang and Li Bang in the future.

2. Cruelty is more than kindness; Lack of advice, magnanimous monarchy. Several small fragments in historical records;

Shinhan led the troops to defect. Xiang Yu was not good at supervising surrender, but turned it into his own use. On the contrary, "more than 200,000 soldiers were attacked at night", fearing that they would refuse to surrender.

When Xinfeng Hongmen heard that Liu Bang was going to be king in Guanzhong, Xiang Yu was furious and wanted to crush Liu Bang10,000,000 troops with 400,000 troops. Liu Bang was afraid that he would woo Xiang Bo, the father of Xiang Yu's Jishi family. He bowed in praise of Wang Xiang. Xiang Yu was obviously complacent and quite proud, so he listened to Xiang Bo and "met" Liu Bang. This is the eternal regret that Fan Zeng "counted the kings" and "the kings were silent" at the Hongmen banquet.

After entering the customs. Xiang Yu "marched west to slaughter Xianyang, killed Qin, and burned Qin Gong. The fire will not go out in March, and the woman will take the goods to the east. " Let the Qin people down.

Eliminate Qin. Someone advised Xiang Yu: "Guanzhong is separated by mountains and rivers, and the land is rich and fertile, but it can unify the world." Xiang Yu turned his heart to the East and said, "If a man is rich and doesn't return to his hometown, it's like dressing up at night. Who knows? " Seeing that Xiang Yu was so short-sighted and disheartened, the admonisher said, "People say that Chu people' bathe monkeys and crown their ears', and it really happened." Xiang Yu was furious when he heard that, "said the cook.

In the winter of the second year of Han Dynasty. Due to improper sealing, Tian Rong rebelled. After Xiang Yu's rebellion, "Tian Rong, who was trapped in the pit, swore to surrender to the death, was captured by his old, weak women and children, and went to Beihai together, and most of them were destroyed."

Xiang Yu's character weakness runs through his life, and he seems to have no intention of changing, which is fatal to a hero with great ambitions and ideals. His growth process is only a brave growth history, but he ignores the pursuit and shaping of higher-level personality. His failure is inevitable, but he is just a strong soldier.